227
Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.
1. At this time Rhodo,1535 a native of Asia, who had been instructed, as he himself states,
by Tatian, with whom we have already become acquainted,1536 having written several books,
published among the rest one against the heresy of Marcion.1537 He says that this heresy
was divided in his time into various opinions;1538 and while describing those who occasioned
the division, he refutes accurately the falsehoods devised by each of them.
2. But hear what he writes:1539
1535 We know nothing of Rhodo except what is contained in this chapter. Jerome gives a very brief account
of him in his de vir. ill. 37, but it rests solely upon this chapter, with the single addition of the statement that
Rhodo wrote a work Against the Phrygians.It is plain enough, however, that he had for his account no independent
source, and that he in this statement simply attributed to Rhodo the work quoted by Eusebius as an anonymous
work in chap. 16. Jerome permits himself such unwarranted combinations very frequently, and we need not be
at all surprised at it. With him a guess is often as good as knowledge, and in this case he doubtless considered
his guess a very shrewd one. There is no warrant for supposing that he himself saw the work mentioned by Eu-
sebius, and thus learned its authorship. What Eusebius did not learn from it he certainly could not, and his
whole account betrays the most slavish and complete dependence upon Eusebius as his only source. In chap.
39 Jerome mentions Rhodo again as referring, in a book which he wrote against Montanus, Prisca, and Maximilla,
to Miltiades, who also wrote against the same heretics. This report is plainly enough taken directly from Eusebius,
chap. 17, where Eusebius quotes from the same anonymous work. Jerome’s utterly baseless combination is very
interesting, and significant of his general method. Rhodo’s works are no longer extant, and the only fragments
we have are those preserved by Eusebius in this chapter.
1536 See Bk. IV. chap. 29.
1537 Upon Marcion and Marcionism, see Bk. IV. chap. 11, note 22.
1538 It is noticeable that Rhodo says γνώμας, opinions, not parties. Although the different Marcionites held
various theoretical beliefs, which gave rise to different schools, yet they did not split up into sects, but remained
one church, and retained the one general name of Marcionites, and it is by this general name alone that they
are always referred to by the Fathers. The fact that they could hold such variant beliefs (e.g. one, two, or three
principles; see below, note 9) without splitting up into sects, shows that doctrines were but a side issue with
them, and that the religious spirit was the matter upon which they laid the chief emphasis. This shows the fun-
damental difference between Marcion and the Gnostics.
1539 These fragments of Rhodo are collected and discussed by Routh in his Rel. Sacræ, I. 437–446.
Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.
533
Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.