Chapter IX
.—
Synodical letter
from the council at Constantinople
.
“
To
the right honourable lords our right reverend brethren
and colleagues Damasus, Ambrosius, Britton, Valerianus, Ascholius,
Anemius, Basilius and the rest of the holy bishops assembled in the
great city of Rome, the holy synod of the orthodox bishops assembled at
the great city of Constantinople, sends greeting in the
Lord.
“To recount all the
sufferings inflicted on us by the power of the Arians, and to attempt
to give information to your reverences, as though you were not already
well acquainted with them, might seem superfluous. For we do not
suppose your piety to hold what is befalling us as of such secondary
importance as that you stand in any need of information on
matter’s which cannot but evoke your sympathy. Nor indeed were
the storms which beset us such as to escape notice from their
insignificance. Our persecutions are but of yesterday. The sound of
them still rings in the ears alike of those who suffered them and of
those whose love made the sufferers’ pain their own. It was but a
day or two ago, if I may so say, that some released from chains in
foreign lands returned to their own churches through manifold
afflictions; of others who had died in exile the relics were brought
home; others again, even after their return from exile, found the
passion of the heretics still at boiling heat, and, slain by them with
stones as was the blessed Stephen, met with a sadder fate in their own
than in a stranger’s land. Others, worn away with various
cruelties, still bear in their bodies the scars of their wounds and the
marks of Christ.
842
“Who could tell the tale
of fines, of disfranchisements, of individual confiscations, of
intrigues, of outrages, of prisons? In truth all kinds of tribulation
were wrought out beyond number in us, perhaps because we were paying
the penalty of sins, perhaps because the merciful God was trying us by
means of the multitude of our sufferings. For these all thanks to God,
who by means of such afflictions trained his servants and, according to
the multitude of his mercies, brought us again to refreshment. We
indeed needed long leisure, time, and toil to restore the church once
more, that so, like physicians healing the body after long sickness and
expelling its disease by gradual treatment, we might bring her back to
her ancient health of true religion. It is true that on the whole we
seem to have been delivered from the violence of our persecutions and
to be just now recovering the churches which have for a long time been
the prey of the heretics. But wolves are troublesome to us who, though
they have been driven from the byre, yet harry the flocks up and down
the glades, daring to hold rival assemblies, stirring seditions among
the people, and shrinking from nothing which can do damage to the
churches.
“So, as we have already
said, we needs must labour all the longer. Since however you showed
your brotherly love to us by inviting us (as though we were your own
members) by the letters of our most religious emperor to the synod
which you are gathering by divine permission at Rome, to the end that
since we alone were then condemned to suffer persecution, you should
not now, when our emperors are at one with us as to true religion,
reign apart from us, but that we, to use the apostle’s phrase,
843
should reign with you, our prayer was,
if it were possible, all in company to leave our churches, and rather
gratify our longing to see you than consult their needs. For who will
give us wings as of a dove, and we will fly and be at rest?
844
But this course seemed likely to leave
the churches who were just recovering quite undefended, and the
undertaking was to most of us impossible, for, in accordance with the
letters sent a year ago from your holiness after the synod at Aquileia
to the most pious emperor Theodosius, we had journeyed to
Constantinople, equipped only for travelling so far as Constantinople,
and bringing the consent of the bishops remaining in the provinces for
this synod alone. We had been in no expectation of any longer journey
nor had heard a word about it before our arrival at Constantinople. In
addition to all this, and on account of the narrow limits of the
appointed time which allowed of no preparation for a longer journey,
nor of communicating with the bishops of our communion in the provinces
and of obtaining their consent, the journey to Rome was for the
majority impossible. We have therefore adopted the next best course
open to us under the circumstances, both for the better administration
of the church, and for manifesting our love towards you, by strongly
urging our most venerated, and honoured colleagues and brother bishops
Cyriacus, Eusebius and Priscianus, to consent to travel to
you.
“Through them we wish to
make it plain
that our disposition is all for peace with unity for its sole
object, and that we are full of zeal for the right faith. For we,
whether we suffered persecutions, or afflictions, or the threats of
emperors, or the cruelties of princes or any other trial at the hands
of heretics, have undergone all for the sake of the evangelic faith,
ratified by the three hundred and eighteen fathers at Nicæa in
Bithynia. This is the faith which ought to be sufficient for you, for
us, for all who wrest not the word of the true faith; for it is the
ancient faith; it is the faith of our baptism; it is the faith that
teaches us to believe in the name of the Father, of the Son, and of the
Holy Ghost.
“According to this faith
there is one Godhead, Power and Substance of the Father and of the Son
and of the Holy Ghost; the dignity being equal, and the majesty being
equal in three perfect essences
845
and three perfect
persons.
846
Thus there is neither room for the
heresy of Sabellius by the confusion of the essences or destruction of
the individualities; thus the blasphemy of the Eunomians, of the
Arians, and of the Pneumatomachi is nullified, which divides the
substance, the nature and the godhead and superinduces on the uncreated
consubstantial and co-eternal trinity a nature posterior, created and
of a different substance. We moreover preserve unperverted the doctrine
of the incarnation of the Lord, holding the tradition that the
dispensation of the flesh is neither soulless nor mindless nor
imperfect; and knowing full well that God’s Word was perfect
before the ages, and became perfect man in the last days for our
salvation.
“Let this suffice for a
summary of the doctrine which is fearlessly and frankly preached by us,
and concerning which you will be able to be still further satisfied if
you will deign to read the report of the synod of Antioch, and also
that issued last year by the œcumenical council held at
Constantinople, in which we have set forth our confession of the faith
at greater length, and have appended an anathema against the heresies
which innovators have recently inscribed.
“Now as to the particular
administration of individual churches, an ancient custom, as you know,
has obtained, confirmed by the enactment of the holy fathers at
Nicæa, that, in every province, the bishops of the province, and,
with their consent, the neighbouring bishops with them, should perform
ordinations as expediency may require. In conforming with these customs
note that other churches have been administered by us and the priests
of the most famous churches publicly appointed. Accordingly over the
new made (if the expression be allowable) church at Constantinople,
which, as though from a lion’s mouth, we have lately snatched by
God’s mercy from the blasphemy of the heretics, we have ordained
bishop the right reverend and most religious Nectarius, in the presence
of the œcumenical council, with common consent, before the most
religious emperor Theodosius, and with the assent of all the clergy and
of the whole city. And over the most ancient and truly apostolic church
in Syria, where first the noble name of Christians
847
was given them, the bishops of the
province and of the eastern diocese
848
have met
together and canonically ordained bishop the right reverend and most
religious Flavianus, with the consent of all the church, who as though
with one voice joined in expressing their respect for him. This
rightful ordination also received the sanction of the general council.
Of the church at Jerusalem, mother of all the churches, we make known
that the right reverend and most religious Cyril is bishop, who was
some time ago canonically ordained by the bishops of the province, and
has in several places fought a good fight against the Arians. We
beseech your reverence to rejoice at what has thus been rightly and
canonically settled by us, by the intervention of spiritual love and by
the influence of the fear of the Lord, compelling the feelings of men,
and making the edification of churches of more importance than
individual grace or favour. Thus since among us there is agreement in
the faith and Christian charity has been established, we shall cease to
use the phrase condemned by the apostles, ‘I am of Paul and I of
Apollos and I of Cephas,’
849
and all
appearing as Christ’s, who in us is not divided, by God’s
grace we will keep the body of the church unrent, and will boldly stand
at the judgment seat of the Lord.”
These things they wrote against
the madness of Arius, Aetius, and Eunomius; and moreover against
Sabellius, Photinus, Marcellus, Paul of Samosata, and Macedonius.
Similarly they openly condemned the innovation of Apollinarius in the
phrase, “And we preserve the doctrine of the incarnation of the
Lord, holding the tradition that the dispensation of the flesh is
neither soulless, nor mindless, nor imperfect.”
842
Gal. vi. 17
843
1 Cor. iv. 8
844
Ps. lv. 6
845
ὑποστάσεσι
846
προσώποις
847
Acts xi. 26
848
Vide note on p. 53.
849
1 Cor. i. 12