that allowance for our infirmities, which justice itself (according to his doctrine) most abso-
lutely requires, as he supposes divine justice exactly proportions our duty to our ability?
Again, if it be said, that although Christ’s redemption was not necessary to preserve
men from beginning to sin, and getting into a course of sin, because they have sufficient
power in themselves to avoid it; yet it may be necessary to deliver men, after they have by
their own folly brought themselves under the dominion of evil appetites and passions. 117
I answer, if it be so, that men need deliverance from those habits and passions, which are
become too strong for them, yet that deliverance, on our author’s principles, would be no
salvation from sin. For the exercise of passions which are too strong for us, and which we
cannot overcome, is necessary: and he strongly urges, that a necessary evil can be no moral
evil. It is true, it is the effect of evil, as it is the effect of a bad practice, while the man had
power to have avoided it. But then according to Dr. T. that evil cause alone is sin; for he says
expressly, ”The cause of every effect is alone chargeable with the effect it produceth, or which
proceedeth from it.” 118 And as to that sin which was the cause, the man needed no Saviour
from that, having had sufficient power in himself to have avoided it. So that it follows by
our author’s scheme, that none of mankind, neither infants nor adult persons, neither the
more nor less vicious, neither Jews nor Gentiles, neither heathens nor Christians, ever did
or ever could stand in any need of a Saviour; and that, with respect to all, the truth is, Christ
is dead in vain.
If any should say, although all mankind in all ages have sufficient ability to do their
whole duty, and so may by their own power enjoy perfect freedom from sin, yet God foresaw
that they would sin, and that after they had sinned, they would need Christ’s death. I answer,
it is plain, by what the apostle says in those places which were just now mentioned, (Gal. ii.
21. and Gal. iii. 21.) that God would have esteemed it needless to give his Son to die for men,
unless there had been a prior impossibility of their having righteousness by any law; and
that, if there had been a law which could have given life, this other way by the death of Christ
would not have been provided. And this appears to be agreeable to our author’s own sense
of things, by his words which have been cited, wherein he says, ” It would have frustrated
or rendered useless the grace of God, if Christ died to accomplish what was or might have
been effected by law itself, without his death.”
V. It will follow on Dr. T.‘s scheme, not only that Christ’s redemption is needless for
saving from sin, or its consequences, but also that it does no good that way, has no tendency
to any diminution of sin in the world. For as to any infusion of virtue or holiness into the
heart, by divine power through Christ or his redemption, it is altogether inconsistent with
117 See p. 228. and also what he says of the helpless state of the heathen, in paraph. and notes on Rom. vii.
and beginning of chap. viii.
118 Page 128.
1123
CHAPTER I. Proofs from Redemption by Christ.