And as to what Mr. W. says in this place about infants being born in the church, it entirely
diverts the reader to another point (which I shall hereafter particularly consider) wholly
distinct from the subject of the argument; which is about rules of admission into the church,
whenever they are admitted. If persons are born in the church in complete standing, as Mr.
W. supposes, then they are not admitted at all, but in their ancestors. But, however, the
question returns, whether ancestors that are unsanctified, can have a lawful right to come
into the church? Mr. W. holds they may. The subject of the argument is about bringing in
tares into the field, whenever they are brought in, whether sooner or later; and whether tares
have a lawful right, by warrant from Christ, to be in the field; supposing this to intend the
church of Christ. The argument I produced to the contrary was, that the tares were introduced
contrary to the owner’s design, through men’s infirmity and Satan’s procurement. Which
argument, being entirely overlooked by my opponent, I desire it may be now particularly
considered.
When the devil brought in the tares, it is manifest, he brought in something that did
not belong there; and therein counteracted the owner of the field, and did it under that very
notion of crossing his design. An enemy (says the parable) hath done this. But how does this
consist with the tares having a lawful right, by the owner’s warrant and appointment, to
have a standing in his field? If Christ by his institution has, in mercy to unsanctified men,
given them a lawful right to come into the church, that it may be a means of their conversion;
then it is a work of his kindness, as the compassionate Redeemer of souls, to bring them in;
and not the doing of the great enemy and destroyer of souls. If the great Physician of souls
has built his church, as an infirmary, in compassion to those that are sick, for this end, that
they may be brought in and healed there; shall it be said with surprise, when such are found
there, How came those sick people here? And shall the compassionate Physician, who built
the hospital, make answer, An enemy hath done this?
Besides, if Christ has appointed that unsanctified men should come into the church, in
order to their conversion, it would be an instance of the faithfulness of his servants to bring
in such. But the bringing in tares into the field, is not represented as owing to the faithfulness
and watchfulness of the servants; but on the contrary, is ascribed to their sleepiness and re-
missness. They were brought in while they slept, who ought to have done the part of
watchmen, in keeping them out, and preventing the designs of the subtle enemy that brought
them in.—Perhaps some would be ready to make the reflection that those churches whose
practice is agreeable to the loose principles Mr. W. espouses, do that at noon-day, in the
presence of God, angels, and men, which the devil did in the dead of the night, while men
slept!
Again, Mr. W. in his reply to my argument from that christian brotherly love, which is
required towards all members of the visible church, goes entirely off from the argument, to
things quite alien from it. His first answer (p. 69. c.) is, that the exercise of this christian love
1976
SECTION III. Irrelevant arguments.