Chapter 11.—Against the Platonists, Who Argue from the Physical Weight of the Ele-
ments that an Earthly Body Cannot Inhabit Heaven.
But against this great gift of God, these reasoners, “whose thoughts the Lord knows that
they are vain”1626 bring arguments from the weights of the elements; for they have been
taught by their master Plato that the two greatest elements of the world, and the furthest
removed from one another, are coupled and united by the two intermediate, air and water.
And consequently they say, since the earth is the first of the elements, beginning from the
base of the series, the second the water above the earth, the third the air above the water,
the fourth the heaven above the air, it follows that a body of earth cannot live in the heaven;
for each element is poised by its own weight so as to preserve its own place and rank. Behold
with what arguments human infirmity, possessed with vanity, contradicts the omnipotence
of God! What, then, do so many earthly bodies do in the air, since the air is the third element
from the earth? Unless perhaps He who has granted to the earthly bodies of birds that they
be carried through the air by the lightness of feathers and wings, has not been able to confer
upon the bodies of men made immortal the power to abide in the highest heaven. The
earthly animals, too, which cannot fly, among which are men, ought on these terms to live
under the earth, as fishes, which are the animals of the water, live under the water. Why,
then, can an animal of earth not live in the second element, that is, in water, while it can in
the third? Why, though it belongs to the earth, is it forthwith suffocated if it is forced to
live in the second element next above earth, while it lives in the third, and cannot live out
of it? Is there a mistake here in the order of the elements, or is not the mistake rather in
their reasonings, and not in the nature of things? I will not repeat what I said in the thirteenth
book,1627 that many earthly bodies, though heavy like lead, receive from the workman’s
hand a form which enables them to swim in water; and yet it is denied that the omnipotent
Worker can confer on the human body a property which shall enable it to pass into heaven
and dwell there.
But against what I have formerly said they can find nothing to say, even though they
introduce and make the most of this order of the elements in which they confide. For if the
order be that the earth is first, the water second, the air third, the heaven fourth, then the
soul is above all. For Aristotle said that the soul was a fifth body, while Plato denied that it
was a body at all. If it were a fifth body, then certainly it would be above the rest; and if it
is not a body at all, so much the more does it rise above all. What, then, does it do in an
1626 Ps. xciv. 11.
1627 C. 18.
Against the Platonists, Who Argue from the Physical Weight of the Elements that an Earthly Body Cannot Inhabit Heaven.
1102
Against the Platonists, Who Argue from the Physical Weight of the Elements…