If, then, there is one word that
will cover the whole meaning, it would seem to be
“Conception.” This word at all events, both in its outward
form and in its intention, stands to perception in a way strictly
analogous to that in which ᾽Επίνοια stands to ῎Εννοια. Both Conception and ᾽Επίνοια represent some regulated operation of the mind upon data
immediately given. In both cases the mind is led to contemplate in a
new light its own contents, whether sensations or innate ideas. The
fitness of Conception as an equivalent of ᾽Επίνοια will be clear when we consider the real point at issue between
Basil and Eunomius. Their controversy rages round the term Ungenerate.
Is it, or is it not, expressive of the substance (being) of the Deity?
To answer this question, it was found necessary to ascertain how such a
name for the Supreme has been acquired. “By a conception,”
says Basil. “No,” says Eunomius: “it would be
dangerous to trust the naming of the Deity to a common operation of the
mind. The faculty of Conception may and does play us false; it can
create monstrosities. Besides, if the names of the Father are
conceptions, the names of the Son are too; for instance, the Door, the
Shepherd, the Axe, the Vine. But as our Lord Himself applied these to
Himself, He would, according to you, be employing the faculty of
conception; and it is blasphemous to think that He employed names which
we too might have arrived at by conceiving of Him in these particular
ways. Therefore, Conception is not the Source of the Divine Names; but
rather they come from a perception or intention implanted in us
directly from on High. Ungenerate is such a name; and it reveals to us
the very substance of the Deity.” But Gregory defends
Basil’s position. He shows the entire relativity of our knowledge
of the Deity. Ungenerate and every other name of God is due to a
conception; in each case we perceive either an operation of the
Deity, or an element of evil, and then we conceive of Him as
operating in the one, or as free from the other; and so name Him. But
there is no conception, because there is no perception, of the
substance of the Deity. Scripture, which has revealed His operations,
has not revealed that. “The human mind…feels after the
unutterable Being in divers and many-sided ways; and never chases the
mystery in the light of one idea alone. Our grasping of Him would
indeed be easy, if there lay before us one single assigned path to the
knowledge of God; but, as it is, from the skill apparent in the
Universe, we get the idea of skill in the Ruler of the
Universe;…and again, when we see the execrable character of evil,
we grasp His own unalterable pureness as regards this,…not that
we split up the subject of such attributes along with them, but,
believing that this Being, whatever it be in substance, is one, we
still conceive that it has something in common with all these
ideas.”