2. So away with Novatus the
Carthaginian was the chief ally of Novatian, who, about the middle of
the third century, founded the sect of the Cathari, or
pure. The allusion is to the severity with which they treated
the lapsed.Novatus, who would not hold out a
hand to the erring! perish Maximilla
and Priscilla, who forsook their husbands and followed him, professing
to be inspired prophetesses. Circ. a.d. 150.
Montanus, like Novatian, refused to re-admit the lapsed.Montanus
and his mad women! Montanus, who would hurl the fallen into the abyss
that they may never rise again. Every day we all sin and make some slip
or other. Being then merciful to ourselves, we are not rigorous towards
others; nay, rather, we pray and beseech That is,
John.him either to simply tell us our own
faults, or to openly defend those of other men. I dislike ambiguities;
I dislike to be told what is capable of two meanings. Let us
contemplate with 2 Cor. iii. 18.unveiled face
the glory of the Lord. Once upon a time the people of Israel halted In Jerome’s
text, “limped in both its feet.” It seemed better to give
the accepted meaning. between two opinions. But, said Elias,
which is by interpretation the strong one of the Lord, 1 Kings xviii. 21.“How long halt ye between two
opinions? If the Lord be God, go after him; but if Baal, follow
him.” And the Lord himself says concerning the Jews, Ps. xviii. 45. “the strange children lied unto
me; the strange children became feeble, and limped out of their
by-paths.” If there really is no ground for suspecting him of
heresy (as I wish and believe), why does he not speak out my opinion in
my own words? He calls it simplicity; I interpret it as artfulness. He
wishes to convince me that his belief is sound; let his speech, then,
also be sound. And, indeed, if the ambiguity attached to a single word,
or a single statement, or two or three, I could be indulgent on the
score of ignorance; nor would I judge what is obscure or doubtful by
the standard of what is certain and clear. But, as things are, this
“simplicity” is nothing but a platform trick, like walking
on tiptoe over eggs or standing corn; there is doubt and suspicion
everywhere. You might suppose he was not writing an exposition of the
faith, but was writing a disputation on some imaginary theme. What he
is now so keen upon, we learnt long ago in the schools. He puts on our
own armour to fight against us. Even if his faith be correct, and he
speaks with circumspection and reserve, his extreme care rouses my
suspicions. Prov. x. 9.“He that walketh uprightly,
walketh boldly.” It is folly to bear a bad name for nothing. A
charge is brought against him of which he is not conscious. Let him
confidently deny the charge which hangs upon a single word, and freely
turn the tables against his adversary. Let the one exhibit the same
boldness in repelling the charge which the other shows in advancing it.
And when he has said all that he
wishes and purposes to say, and such things as are above suspicion, if
his opponent persists in slander, let him try conclusions in open
court. I wish no one to sit still under an imputation of heresy, lest,
if he say nothing, his want of openness be interpreted, amongst those
who are not aware of his innocence, as the consciousness of guilt,
although there is no need to demand the presence of a man and to reduce
him to silence when you have his letters in your possession.