Here Gregory is in
error, for in the eighth, ninth, and tenth sessions of the council of
Chalcedon Theodoret and Ibas, whose writings were anathematized in that
fifth council, were heard in their own defence, and definitely
acquitted of heresy. It is true that there is no mention of them
in the Definition of faith, agreed upon in the fifth session of
Chalcedon, or in the Canons which were perhaps all that Gregory had
before him. It is true also that there was no reference at
Chalcedon to Theodore of Mopsuestia, who was especially and personally
anathematized at the fifth council, he having died many years before
the council of Chalcedon was held. But the cases of Theodoret and
Ibas had been prominently before the synod; and this not, as Gregory
here goes on to intimate, in a supplementary sort of way at the end of
the main proceedings: for the eighth, ninth, and tenth sessions
had been occupied with them, after which there had been other
sessions. For similar inaccuracy on Gregory’s part in
referring to past events, see II. 51, note 2; and for an instance of
his imperfect acquaintance with the history of past controversies, see
VII. 4.