2. For what have they discovered in this heresy
like to the religious Faith, that they vainly talk as if its supporters
said no evil? This in truth is to call even Caiaphas de
Decr. §§2, 24, 27. a Christian, and to reckon the traitor Judas
still among the Apostles, and to
say that they who asked Barabbas instead of the Saviour did no evil,
and to recommend Hymenæus and Alexander as right-minded men, and
as if the Apostle slandered them. But neither can a Christian bear to
hear this, nor can he consider the man who dared to say it sane in his
understanding. For with them for Christ is Arius, as with the Manichees
Manichæus; and for Moses and the other saints they have made the
discovery of one Sotades de
Syn. §1., a man whom even
Gentiles laugh at, and of the daughter of Herodias. For of the one has
Arius imitated the dissolute and effeminate tone, in writing
Thaliæ on his model; and the other he has rivalled in her dance,
reeling and frolicking in his blasphemies against the Saviour; till the
victims of his heresy lose their wits and go foolish, and change the
Name of the Lord of glory into the likeness of the ‘image of
corruptible man Vid.
Hil. de Trin. viii. 28; Rom. i. 25.,’ and for
Christians come to be called Arians, bearing this badge of their
irreligion. For let them not excuse themselves; nor retort their
disgrace on those who are not as they, calling Christians after the
names of their teachers He
seems to allude to Catholics being called Athanasians; vid. however
next §. Two distinctions are drawn between such a title as applied
to Catholics, and again to heretics, when they are taken by Catholics
as a note against them. S. Augustine says, ‘Arians
call Catholics Athanasians or Homoüsians, not other heretics
too. But ye not only by Catholics but also by heretics,
those who agree with you and those who disagree, are called Pelagians;
as even by heresies are Arians called Arians. But ye, and ye
only, call us Traducianists, as Arians call us Homoüsians, as
Donatists Macarians, as Manichees Pharisees, and as the other heretics
use various titles.’ Op. imp. i. 75. It may be added that
the heretical name adheres, the Catholic dies away. S.
Chrysostom draws a second distinction, ‘Are we divided from the
Church? have we heresiarchs? are we called from man? is there any
leader to us, as to one there is Marcion, to another Manichæus, to
another Arius, to another some other author of heresy? for if we too
have the name of any, still it is not those who began the heresy,
but our superiors and governors of the Church. We have not
“teachers upon earth,”’ &c. in Act. Ap.
Hom. 33 fin., that they
themselves may appear to have that Name in the same way. Nor let them
make a jest of it, when they feel shame at their disgraceful
appellation; rather, if they be ashamed, let them hide their faces, or
let them recoil from their own irreligion. For never at any time did
Christian people take their title from the Bishops among them, but from
the Lord, on whom we rest our faith. Thus, though the blessed Apostles
have become our teachers, and have ministered the Saviour’s
Gospel, yet not from them have we our title, but from Christ we are and
are named Christians. But for those who derive the faith which they
profess from others, good reason is it they should bear their name,
whose property they have become Vid.
foregoing note. Also, ‘Let us become His disciples, and learn to
live according to Christianity; for whoso is called by other name
besides this, is not of God.’ Ignat. ad Magn. 10.
Hegesippus speaks of ‘Menandrians, and Marcionites, and
Carpocratians, and Valentinians, and Basilidians, and
Saturnilians,’ who ‘each in his own way and that a
different one brought in his own doctrine.’ Euseb. Hist.
iv. 22. ‘There are, and there have been, my friends, many who
have taught atheistic and blasphemous words and deeds, coming in the
name of Jesus; and they are called by us from the appellation of the
men, whence each doctrine and opinion began.…Some are called
Marcians, others Valentinians, others Basilidians, others
Saturnilians,’ &c. Justin. Tryph. 35. Iren.
Hær. i. 23. ‘When men are called Phrygians, or
Novatians, or Valentinians, or Marcionites, or Anthropians, or by any
other name, they cease to be Christians; for they have lost
Christ’s Name, and clothe themselves in human and foreign
titles.’ Lact. Inst. iv. 30. ‘A. How are you a
Christian, to whom it is not even granted to bear the name of
Christian? for you are not called Christian but Marcionite. M. And you
are called of the Catholic Church; therefore ye are not Christians
either. A. Did we profess man’s name, you would have spoken to
the point; but if we are called from being all over the world, what is
there bad in this?’ Adamant. Dial. §1, p. 809. Epiph.
Hær. 42. p. 366. ibid. 70. 15. vid. also Hær.
75. 6 fin. Cyril Cat. xviii. 26. ‘Christian is my name,
Catholic my surname.’ Pacian. Ep. 1. ‘If you ever
hear those who are called Christians, named, not from the Lord Jesus
Christ, but from some one else, say Marcionites, Valentinians,
Mountaineers, Campestrians, know that it is not Christ’s Church,
but the synagogue of Antichrist.’ Jerom. adv. Lucif.
fin..