59. Your narratives, my opponent says, are overrun with barbarisms and solecisms, and
disfigured by monstrous blunders. A censure, truly, which shows a childish and petty spirit;
for if we allow that it is reasonable, let us cease to use certain kinds of fruit because they
grow with prickles on them, and other growths useless for food, which on the one hand
cannot support us, and yet do not on the other hinder us from enjoying that which specially
excels, and which nature has designed to be most wholesome for us. For how, I pray you,
does it interfere with or retard the comprehension of a statement, whether anything be
pronounced smoothly3358 or with uncouth roughness? whether that have the grave accent
which ought to have the acute, or that have the acute which ought to have the grave? Or
how is the truth of a statement diminished, if an error is made in number or case, in prepos-
ition, participle, or conjunction? Let that pomposity of style and strictly regulated diction
be reserved for public assemblies, for lawsuits, for the forum and the courts of justice, and
by all means be handed over to those who, striving after the soothing influences of pleasant
sensations, bestow all their care upon splendour of language. But when we are discussing
matters far removed from mere display, we should consider what is said, not with what
charm it is said nor how it tickles the ears, but what benefits it confers on the hearers, espe-
cially since we know that some even who devoted themselves to philosophy, not only disreg-
arded refinement of style, but also purposely adopted a vulgar meanness when they might
have spoken with greater elegance and richness, lest forsooth they might impair the stern
gravity of speech and revel rather in the pretentious show of the Sophists. For indeed it
evidences a worthless heart to seek enjoyment in matters of importance; and when you have
to deal with those who are sick and diseased, to pour into their ears dulcet sounds, not to
apply a remedy to their wounds. Yet, if you consider the true state of the case, no language
is naturally perfect, and in like manner none is faulty. For what natural reason is there, or
what law written in the constitution of the world, that paries should be called hic,3359 and
sella hæc?—since neither have they sex distinguished by male and female, nor can the most
learned man tell me what hic and hæc are, or why one of them denotes the male sex while
the other is applied to the female. These conventionalities are man’s, and certainly are not
indispensable to all persons for the use of forming their language; for paries might perhaps
have been called hæc, and sella hic, without any fault being found, if it had been agreed upon
at first that they should be so called, and if this practice had been maintained by following
generations in their daily conversation. And yet, O you who charge our writings with dis-
graceful blemishes, have you not these solecisms in those most perfect and wonderful books
of yours? Does not one of you make the plur. of uter, utria? another utres?3360 Do you not
3358 So Orelli and Hildebrand, reading glabre from a conjecture of Grotius, for the ms. grave.
3359 i.e., that the one should be masculine, the other feminine.
3360 i.e., does not one of you make the plural of uter masc., another neut.? [Note the opponent’s witness to
the text of the Gospels.]
Chapter LIX.
979
Chapter LIX.