On
Tatian and his writings, see below, chap. 29.
Eusebius has been accused by
Dembowski, Zahn, Harnack, and others of practicing deception at this
point. The passage from Tatian’s Oratio ad Græcos,
which Eusebius appeals to for testimony in regard to Justin’s
death, and which he quotes just below, is not given by him exactly as
it stands in the extant text of the Oratio. In the latter we
read, “He who taught that death should be despised was himself so
greatly in fear of it, that he endeavored to inflict death as if it
were an evil upon Justin, and indeed on me also, because when
preaching he had proved that the philosophers were gluttons and
impostors.” The difference between the two texts consists in the
substitution of the word μεγ€λῳ for
the words καὶ
ἐμὲ ὡς; and it is
claimed that this alteration was intentionally made by Eusebius. As the
text stands in Tatian, the passage is far from proving that
Justin’s death was caused by the machinations of Crescens, for
Tatian puts himself on a level with Justin as the object of these
machinations, and of course since they did not succeed in his case,
there is no reason to suppose that they succeeded in Justin’s
case. It is claimed, therefore, that Justin, realizing this, struck out
the καὶ
ἐμὲ ὡς in order to
permit the reader to gather from the passage that Tatian meant to imply
that the plots of Crescens were successful, and resulted in
Justin’s death. Before accepting this conclusion, however, it may
be well to realize exactly what is involved in it. The change does not
consist merely in the omission of the words καὶ ἐμὲ
ὡς, but in the substitution for them
of the word μεγ€λῳ. It
cannot, therefore, be said that Eusebius only omitted some words,
satisfying his conscience that there was no great harm in that; whoever
made the change, if he did it intentionally, directly falsified the
text, and substituted the other word for the sake of covering up his
alteration; that is, he committed an act of deceit of the worst kind,
and deliberately took steps to conceal his act. Certainly such conduct
is not in accord with Eusebius’ general character, so far as we
can ascertain it from his writings. Even Zahn and Harnack, who accuse
him of intentional deception here, yet speak of his general
conscientiousness, and treat this alteration as one which Eusebius
allowed himself to make while, at the same time, his
“conscientiousness did not permit him even this time to change
truth completely into untruth.” But if he could allow himself to
make so deliberate an alteration, and then cover the change by
inserting another word, there is little cause to speak of
“conscientiousness” in connection with the matter; if he
could do that, his conscience would certainly permit him to make any
false quotations, however great, so long as he thought he could escape
detection. But few would care to accuse Eusebius of possessing such a
character. Certainly if he possessed it, we should find clearer traces
of it than we do in his History, where we have the opportunity
to control a large portion of his statements on an immense variety of
subjects. Moreover, for such a grave act of deception as Eusebius is
supposed to have committed, some adequate ground must have existed. But
what ground was there? The only motive suggested is that he desired to
appear to possess specific knowledge about the manner of Justin’s
death, when in fact he did not possess it. It is not maintained that he
had any larger motive, such as reconciling apparent contradictions in
sacred records, or shedding an added luster upon the Christian
religion, for neither of these purposes has any relation to the
statement in regard to Crescens’ connection with Justin’s
death. Solely then for the sake of producing the impression that he
knew more about Justin’s death than he did, he must have made the
change. But certainly when we realize how frequently Eusebius directly
avows his ignorance on points far more important (to his mind) than
this (e.g., the dates of the Jerusalem bishops, which he might so
easily have invented), and when we consider how sober his history is in
comparison with the accounts of the majority of his contemporaries,
both Pagan and Christian, how few fables he introduces, how seldom he
embellishes the narratives which he finds related in his sources with
imaginary figments of his own brain,—when, in fact, no such
instances can be found elsewhere, although, writing in the age he did,
and for the public for whom he did, he might have invented so many
stories without fear of detection, as his successors during the ancient
and middle ages were seldom loath to do,—when all this is taken
into consideration, we should hesitate long before we accuse Eusebius
of such deceptive conduct as is implied in the intentional alteration
of Tatian’s account at this point. It has been quite the custom
to accuse Eusebius of intentional deviations from the truth here and
there but it must be remembered that he was either honest or dishonest,
and if he ever deliberately and intentionally deviated from the truth,
his general character for truthfulness is gone, unless the deviation
were only in some exceptional case, where the pressure to
misrepresentation was unusually strong, under which circumstances his
reputation for veracity in general might not be seriously impaired. But
the present instance is not such an one, and if he was false here on so
little provocation, why should we think his character such as to
guarantee truthfulness in any place where falsehood might be more
desirable?
The fact is, however, that the
grounds upon which the accusation against Eusebius is based are very
slender. Nothing but the strongest evidence should lead us to conclude
that such a writer as he practiced such wilful deception for reasons
absolutely trivial. But when we realize how little is known of the
actual state of the text of Tatian’s Oratio at the time
Eusebius wrote, we must acknowledge that to base an accusation on a
difference between the text of the History and the extant mss. of the Oratio is at least a little
hasty. An examination of the latest critical edition of Tatian’s
Oratio (that of Schwartz, in Gebhardt, and Harnack’s
Texte und Untersuch. IV. 1) shows us that in a number of
instances the testimony of the mss. of
Eusebius is accepted over against that of the few extant mss. of Tatian. The ms. of Tatian
which Eusebius used was therefore admittedly different at a number of
points from all our existing mss. of Tatian.
It is consequently not at all impossible that the ms. which he used read μεγ€λῳ instead of καὶ
ἐμὲ ὡς. It happens,
indeed, to be a fact that our three mss. of
Tatian all present variations at this very point (one reads
καὶ ἐμὲ
ὡς, another, καὶ ἐμὲ
οἷον, another,
καὶ ἐμὲ
οὗς), showing that the
archetype, whatever it was, either offered difficulties to the
copyists, or else was partially illegible, and hence required
conjectural emendations or additions. It will be noticed that the
closing verb of this sentence is in the singular, so that the mention
of both Justin and Tatian in the beginning of the sentence may well
have seemed to some copyist quite incongruous, and it is not difficult
to suppose that under such circumstances, the text at this point being
in any case obscure or mutilated, such a copyist permitted himself to
make an alteration which was very clever and at the same time did away
with all the trouble. Textual critics will certainly find no difficulty
in such an assumption. The mss. of Tatian are
undoubtedly nearer the original form at this point than those of
Eusebius, but we have no good grounds for supposing that Eusebius did
not follow the ms. which lay before
him.
The question as to
Eusebius’ interpretation of the passage as he found it is quite a
different one. It contains no direct statement that Justin met his
death in consequence of the plots of Crescens; and finding no mention
of such a fact in the Acts of Martyrdom of Justin, we may dismiss it as
unhistorical and refuse to accept Eusebius’ interpretation of
Tatian’s words. To say, however, that Eusebius intentionally
misinterpreted those words is quite unwarranted. He found in
Justin’s work an expressed expectation that he would meet his
death in this way, and he found in Tatian’s work the direct
statement that Crescens did plot Justin’s death as the latter had
predicted he would. There was nothing more natural than to conclude
that Tatian meant to imply that Crescens had succeeded, for why did he
otherwise mention the matter at all, Eusebius might well say, looking
at the matter from his point of view, as an historian interested at
that moment in the fact of Justin’s death. He does undoubtedly
show carelessness and lack of penetration in interpreting the passage
as he does; but if he had been aware of the defect in the evidence he
presents, and had yet wished deceitfully to assert the fact as a fact,
he would certainly have omitted the passage altogether, or he would
have bolstered it up with the statement that other writers confirmed
his conclusion,—a statement which only a thoroughly and genuinely
honest man would have scrupled to make. Finally, to return to the
original charge of falsification of the sources, he realized that the
text of Tatian, with the καὶ ἐμὲ ὡς, did not establish Justin’s death at the instigation
of Crescens, he must have realized at the same time that his altered
text, while it might imply it, certainly did not absolutely prove it,
and hence he would not have left his conclusion, which he stated as a
demonstrated fact, to rest upon so slender a basis, when he might so
easily have adduced any number of oral traditions in confirmation of
it. If he were dishonest enough to alter the text, he would not have
hesitated to state in general terms that the fact is “also
supported by tradition.” We conclude, finally, that he read the
passage as we now find it in the mss. of his
History, and that his interpretation of the passage, while
false, was not intentionally so.
The attacks upon
Eusebius which have been already referred to are to be found in
Dembowski’s Quellen der christlichen Apologetik, I. p. 60;
Zahn’s Tatian’s Diatessaron, p. 275 sq., and
Harnack’s Ueberlieferung der griech. Apologeten, p. 141
sq. Semisch (Justin der Märtyrer, I. 53) takes for granted
that Eusebius followed the text of Tatian which lay before him, but
does not attempt to prove it.