5'62
parishes, two m1ss10ns, 570 communicants,
a possible 1,500 adherents, a boys school,
(Iolani CoUege), already thirty-years old,
fifty-two pupils, and a girls' school (the
Priory), thirty-three years old, 150 scholars.
There is to-day just one congregation of na
tive H�waiian Churchmen, and that hardly
deserving the name-only twelve to fifteen
souls.
There are numerous points where the
Church could be started. Hilo, the sec
ond largest city in the islands,has no Church
organization, not e_ven a mission. We found
several Churchmen there who have been
anxious a long time for the services of the
Church.
With the royal patronafle from the be
gin ning, and the · appropriation by the
S. P. G., and also the grand opportunity at
the outset, the Church should be many
times as strong as she is. There ought to
be at least 5,000 communic ants and 10, 000
adherent'>, instead of the meager number
repor ted. From the day one lands in Hawaii,
to bis de.oarture, there is somehow a sad, a
deprE s ,c d Chm c'1Jy feeling weig-hing him
down. He is mortified over th@ condition,
and particularly when he considers what
other relhrious bodies Jaave done and are
to-day doing.
The Methodists were there in 1860, but
gave up in discourageme nt; the Church in
1862, we were told, taking even their bulld
ing for their first place of worship. After
thirty-five years, the Methodists returned,
and now have their nine m �eting houses
and Sunday schools. · Their min ister of
fered the only prayer me ntioned in the an
nexation service lately held at Honolulu.
The Campbellites are there with their one
meeting house, a rapidly growing congre
gation, and a flourishing- SLrnday school.
The Congregationalists have their 64 con
gregations, of which 55 are made up of na
tives, b3sides sepa, rate places for Japanese,
Chinese, and Portuguese converts. The
Romanist s haYe' 93 pari�hes and missions;
communicants, native 14,000, other� 12, 363,
total 26,363. The Mormons came al:Jou t the
same time as the Church , and are 4, 886
strong.
That the Chmch might have taken care
of heirAelf, latterly, independent of outside
assistance 1 is poaitively asserted by one who
has made the matter a c �reful study. He
says: ''Every other religious body in the
Islands is self-supporting. The Chu rch
could have been so ten years ago and so
have wiped out the stig;m3, of being called
a missionary diocese There is no need
of pauperizing her." That she could take
care of her self without the help of the
Board of Mis�ions, is thoroughly believed,
if once thrown upon her own resources and
allowed to work upon the plan of the Amer
ican Church.
The. rector of the second Cathedral con
gregation, the largest and strongest in the
Hawaii, says in hi s August -parish paper:
"C b.urchmen are all anxious to know what
will happen when annexation has formally
taken hold in these · islands. The S. P. G.
will no doubt feel a mixt ure of sorrow and
relief at losi ng· the child it has so carefully
nurture d. _ At the same time, Churchmen
will be tlirown upon their own resources.
The rumors of the wealth hidden in the
islands will preclude all idea of help from
a country so near as the continent c,f
America. "
Painful as the further recit a.l may be, the
tebe 1il'lno <tourcb
following should be more generally known.
Du ring the last 26 years, nearly 40 different
priests of the British and American Church
es have been under the present Ordinary of
Honolulu diocese, but only one or two have
cared to remain any length of time. What
has been true of the Bishop and his clergy,
has been equally true of his relations to the
laity. From 1882 to 1886, a most unfortu
nate and disgraceful quarrel-some called
it a disgusting one-was kept up over finan
cial matters, which fina lly resulted iii a di
vision of the cathedral congregation. A
second congregation was licensed which
took nine-tenths of the people and has ever
si nce held them and controlled nearly all
the financial strength of the Church in the
Capitol City. Although a regular attend
ant upon the Bishop's con!!'regation, we
�eldom saw a dozen adults present, aside
from those connected with the college and
priory schools.
As one serious consequen ce of the divid&d
condition, the completion of the cathedral
building was arrested and it stands, to-day,
a monument of religious dissension and dis
aster. The Bishop was compelled to write
to the S. P. G. as early as 1880: "The inter
est in the movement (compl_etion of the
cathedral) both in England and at the
islands, has lost life."
The noble and godly Queen Emma whose
generous gifts did so much tQ sustain the
services and artistically adorn the bl!ild
ing, for several years became thorm1ghly
discoura!!'ed, and lost her interest in the
Church,and for some time before her death,
transferred her sympathy and beneficences
to other religious bodies.
The Bishop seems to have in various
ways anta�onized his own people, British
and Americans especially, by refusing to
co-operate in any public charitie s, by refus
ing to pray for the president of the Republic
whose sovereignty was his defence and pro
tection, by opposing annexation to the very
last hour, and also by criticising those of
his priests who did pray for the Republic
and for those in authority, or cherish opin
ions favorable to annexation.
We visited Hawaii on a vacation trip
hoping- to find something pleasant to say of
the Church, on reaching home. But we had
not been on the island of Hawaii two hours,
before we beg-an to hear about the Church
troubles. :r n our hotel at the Capitol, a.mong
entire strangers, we were asked at our first
meal, '' If we had heard of the Chur ch scand
als at the c1thedral. " The native Church
people freqltently referred us to their
"Pilikia" (C hurch trouble). We found the
secular press often containing bitter and
sarcastic articles about the difficuHies the
people had with their bishop. Strong and
pointed hint, as to the propriety of his
leaving were repeat edly thrown out. In
deed, in the early nineties, the Bishop was
formally asked by the Church people to re
tire from his jurisdiction in Hawaii.
We heard Churchmen, officials, and others
several times say, "they wished their Bishop
would never return from the Pan-Anglican
Conference to Hawaii." And one of the last
remarks made to us by a lay Ch urch official,
upon taking our home steamer, was that
"they dreaded the moment when be should
al,('ain put his feet on the islands." The
Bishop is unpopular in the Church and out
side the Uhurch. The social, political, and
religious animus there is rebellious against
the present Ordinary.
The Church has lost scores and hun dreds
SEPT. 24, 1898
in the past as a consequence, and she will
lose many more, unless a bishop of Ameri
can antecedents and spirit be placed over
the reorganized Church, while such a chief
pastor would be most cordially welcomed
and heartily supported.
Why? we repeat, is the question the Gen
eral Convention ought to answer, before fin
al steps be takEn to affiliate Hawaiian
Churchmen with the American Church.
Los Angel.es, Ual., Sept. Gth, 1898.
Letters to the Edito1
PROPOSED CHANGE OF NAME
To I.he Editor of The Living Cliu1·ch:
The cominl!' General Convention, it is to be
hoped, will give to this Church her proper title.
The present one is both cumbersome. and inex
pressive. We have neither legal nor ecclesias
tical right to the term •·Protestant." It be
longs solely to the "Lutherans"-was originally
bestowed upon them by Romanists in derision.
We desire nothing of purely Roman origin,
and as one bunch of Methodism lays claim to
the title ''Epi scopal,·, we desire not that. But
what we do want is a name -that will express
the true status of the Church and at the same
time differentiate us from Sectarianism and
Romanism. We recite as an article of the
Catholic Faith a belief in '· one Holy Catholic
and Apostolic Church. " The title page of our
Prayer Book designates the Church as the
"Protestant Episcopal.' ' To outsiders this
seems inconsistent-to express a belief in a
Catholic and Apostolic Church and at the same
time place the namA "Protestant Episcopal '' on
our Standard of Worship. No wonder that
Romanists can say, and with some degree of
reason, "Your name belies your creed.'-'
Io apostolic days the Church took· her name
from the chief cities where the "episcopate"
located their sees ; as, for instance, the Church
at Jerusalem, at Corinth, Ephesus, Rome, Gaul,
Antioch. The e;irly Christians did not deem it
necessary to prefix "Episcopal" ln order to dif
ferentiate their churches from sects that arose
even in their days. They knew that wherever
the threefold order of ministry prevailed -Christ
truly preached and the sacraments duly ad
ministered'---there was the Catholic and Apos
tolic Church.
We speak of our motller Church-the one
that gave us birth-as the Anglo-Catholic
Church, or the Church of England ; of the Ital
ian Mission as the Roman Catholic Church ; of
the various Protestant denominations as ''Dis•
senters. " Analogously, the daughter in these
Un:ted States is the American C,i.tholic Church.
I sincerely hope this title will Prevail. It is the
only correct title that designates her true
status. The Roman Church should not object.
According to the Council of Trent, she is "The·
Holy Roman Catholic Church"- a foreign
Church, with a foreign mission, to teach Rom
anism, not the puraC,i.th ollc Fdith as th e Amer
can Catholic Church teaches.
Sectarians can find no reasonable fault
with the Church for assuming her God-given
rights. They make no claim to being the Cath
olic Church. How could they,. seeing that their
systems date back but a few hundred years.
They are satisfied to be known by the name of
their founders and the peculiar tenets which
they originated. The name •• The American
Catholic Church "is no more exclusive than ''The
Roman Catholic," "The Greek Catholic," "The
Baptist," "The Presbyterian," or '"The Metho
dists."
The Church in assuming this title will simply
proclaim to the world what she · is ; namely, a
branch of the Catholic Church situated in that
portion of the globe designated "America."
There can be no doubt whatever but that this
Church which we call '·The Protestant Episco
pal" is destined in course of time, if she is true
to her mission, to become the spiritual home of