How then is the Son “in
the Father” without being destroyed, and how does the Father,
coming to be “in the Son,” remain continually unconsumed,
if, as Eunomius says, the special attribute of fire, as compared with
water, is maintained in the relation of the Generate to the Ungenerate?
Nor does their definition regard communion as existing between earth
and air, for the former is stable, solid, resistent, of downward
tendency and heavy, while air has a nature made up of the contrary
attributes. So white and black are found in opposition among colours,
and men are agreed that the circle is not the same with the triangle,
for each, according to the definition of its figure, is precisely that
which the other is not. But I am unable to discover where he sees the
opposition in the case of God the Father and God the Only-begotten Son.
One goodness, wisdom, justice, providence, power,
incorruptibility,—all other attributes of exalted significance
are similarly predicated of each, and the one has in a certain sense
His strength in the other; for on the one hand the Father makes all
things through the Son, and on the other hand the Only-begotten works
all in Himself, being the Power of the Father. Of what avail, then, are
fire and water to show essential diversity in the Father and the Son?
He calls us, moreover, “rash” for instancing the unity of
nature and difference of persons of Peter and Paul, and says we are
guilty of gross recklessness, if we apply our argument to the
contemplation of the objects of pure reason by the aid of material
examples. Fitly, fitly indeed, does the corrector of our errors reprove
us for rashness in interpreting the Divine Nature by material
illustrations! Why then, deliberate and circumspect sir, do you talk
about the elements? Is earth immaterial, fire an object of pure reason,
water incorporeal, air beyond the perception of the senses? Is your
mind so well directed to its aim, are you so keen-sighted in all
directions in your promulgation of this argument, that your adversaries
cannot lay hold of, that you do not see in yourself the faults you
blame in those you are accusing? Or are we to make concessions to you
when you are establishing the diversity of essence by material aid, and
to be ourselves rejected when we point out the kindred character of the
Nature by means of examples within our compass?