Origen, Gregory’s master in most of his theology, did teach
this very thing, the pre-existence of the soul: nor did he attempt to
deny that some degree of transmigration was a necessary
accompaniment of such teaching; only he would adjust the moral meaning
of it. Cf. c. Celsum, Lib. iii. 75. “And even if we should
treat (i e. medically) those who have caught the folly of the
transmigration of souls from doctors who push down a reasoning nature
into any of the unreasoning natures, or even into that which is
insensate, how can any say that we shall not work improvement in their
souls by teaching them that the bad do not have allotted to them by way
of punishment that insensate or unreasoning state, but that what is
inflicted by God upon the bad, be it pain or affliction, is only in the
way of a very efficacious cure for them? This is the teaching of the
wise Christian: he attempts to teach the simpler of his flock as
fathers do the merest infants.” Not the theory itself, but the
exaggeration of it, is here combated.