CHAP. VL] the holy SPIEIT NOT INCAENATE IN THE DOVE. 53
not mean flesh without soul and without mind ; but " all flesh,"
is the same as if it were said, every man. The creature, then,
in which the Holy Spirit should appear, was not so taken, as
that flesh and human form were taken, of the Virgin Mary.
For the Spirit did not beatify the dove, or the wind, or the fire,
and jointhem for ever to Himself and to His person in unity and
" fashion.** Nor, again, is the nature of the Holy Spirit mutable
and changeable ; so that these things were not made of the
creature, but He himself was turned and changed first into
one and then into another, as water is changed into ice. But
these things appeared at the seasons at which they ought to
have appeared, the creature serving the Creator, and being
changed and converted at the command of Him who remains
immutably in Himself, in order to signify and manifestHim in
such way as it was fit He should be signified and manifested
to mortal men. Accordingly, although that dove is called
the Spirit;^ and in speaking of that fire, "There appeared
unto them," he says, " cloven tongues, like as of fire, and it
sat upon each of them ; and they began to speak with other
tongues, as the Spirit gave them utterance ;"^ in order to show
that the Spirit was manifested by that fire, as by the dove
;
yet we cannot call the Holy Spirit both God and a dove, or
both God and fire, in the same way as we call the Son both
God and man ; nor as we call the Son the Lamb of God ; which
not only John the Baptist says, " Behold the Lamb of God," ^
but also John the Evangelist sees the Lamb slain in the
Apocalypse.* For that prophetic vision was not shown to
bodily eyes through bodily forms, but in the spirit through
spiritual images of bodily things. But whosoever saw that
dove and that fire, saw them with their eyes. Although it
may perhaps be disputed concerning the fire, whether it was
seen by the eyes or in the spirit, on account of the form of
the sentence. For the text does not say, They saw cloven
tongues like fire, but, " There appeared to them." But we are
not wont to say with the same meaning. It appeared to me
;
as we say, I saw. And in those spiritual visions of corporeal
images the usual expressions are, both. It appeared to me
;
1 Matt. iii. 16. - Acts ii. 3, 4.
3 John i. 29. * Apoc. v. G.