The History of the Arians, then, is a complete
work, and written to continue the narrative of the second part of the
Apology. Being in fact a manifesto against Constantius, it naturally
takes up the tale just before his entry upon the scene as the patron of
Arianism. The substantially Athanasian authorship of the History cannot
be questioned. The writer occasionally, like many others ancient and
modern, speaks of himself in the third person (references §21,
note 5, see also Orat. i. 3); but in other places he clearly
identifies himself with Athanasius. The only passage which appears to
distinguish the writer from Athanasius (§52, see note), may be due
to the bishop’s habitual (Apol. Const. 11) employment of
an amanuensis, but more probably the text is corrupt; in any case the
passage cannot weigh against the clear sense of §21. The
immediate Athanasian authorship of the piece has been questioned
partly on the ground of its alleged incompleteness, partly on that of
several slight discrepancies with other writings. On this twofold
ground it is inferred that the Arian History has passed through some
obscure process of re-editing (Gwatkin, Studies, p. 99, §14
‘dependent on the Vita [Antonii] 86,’ p. 127,
‘not an uncorrupted work’) by a later hand. I am quite
unconvinced of this. The incompleteness of the work is, as I think I
have shewn above, an unnecessary hypothesis, while the mistakes or
inconsistencies may well be due to circumstances of composition. It was
written in hiding, perhaps while moving from place to place, certainly
under more pressure of highly wrought agitation and bitterness of
spirit than any other work of Athanasius. The most accurate of men when
working at leisure make strange slips at times (e.g. §13, note 4);
the mistakes in the History are not more than one might expect in such
a work. The principal are, §21 (see note 3), §14 (reference
in note 8), §11, πρὶν
γενέσθαι
ταῦτα (cf. Encycl. 5), §47
(inverting order of events in §39).