(5.) We abhor besides, and anathematize those who
make a pretence of saying that He is but the mere word of God and
unexisting, having His being in another,—now as if pronounced, as
some speak, now as mental The
use of the words ἐνδιάθετος
and προφορικός, mental and pronounced, to distinguish the
two senses of λόγος,
reason and word, came from the school of the Stoics, and
is found in Philo, and was under certain limitations allowed in
Catholic theology, Damasc. F. O. ii. 21. To use either
absolutely and to the exclusion of the other would have involved some
form of Sabellianism, or Arianism as the case might be; but each might
correct the defective sense of either. S. Theophilus speaks of our Lord
as at once ἐνδιάθετος
and προφορικός. ad Autol. ii. 10 and 22, S. Cyril as ἐνδιάθετος, in Joann. p. 39. but see also Thesaur. p.
47. When the Fathers deny that our Lord is the προφορικὸς
λόγος, they only mean
that that title is not, even as far as its philosophical idea went, an
adequate representative of Him, a word spoken being insubstantive, vid.
Orat. ii. 35; Hil. de Syn. 46; Cyr. Catech. xi.
10; Damas. Ep. ii. p. 203; Cyril in Joann. p. 31; Iren.
Hær. ii. 12. n. 5. Marcellus is said by Eusebius to have
considered our Lord as first the one and then the other. Eccl.
Theol. ii. 15.,—holding that
He was not Christ or Son of God or mediator or image of God before
ages; but that He first became Christ and Son of God, when He took our
flesh from the Virgin, not quite four hundred years since. For they
will have it that then Christ began His Kingdom, and that it will have
an end after the consummation of all and the judgment This
passage seems taken from Eusebius, and partly from Marcellus’s
own words. S. Cyril speaks of his doctrine in like terms.
Catech. xv. 27.. Such are the disciples of Marcellus and
Scotinus i.e.
Photinus. [A note illustrating the frequency of similar nicknames is
omitted. On Photinus, see Prolegg. ch. ii. §3. ad
fin.] of Galatian Ancyra, who, equally with
Jews, negative Christ’s existence before ages, and His Godhead,
and unending Kingdom, upon pretence of supporting the divine Monarchy.
We, on the contrary, regard Him not as simply God’s pronounced
word or mental, but as Living God and Word, existing in Himself, and
Son of God and Christ; being and abiding with His Father before ages,
and that not in foreknowledge only Cf.
Euseb. contr. Marc. i. 2., and
ministering to Him for the whole framing whether of things visible or
invisible. For He it is, to whom the Father said, ‘Let Us make
man in Our image, after Our likeness Cf.
§27, notes.’ (Gen. i. 26), who also was seen in His own Person αὐτοπροσωπῶς
and so Cyril Hier. Catech. xv. 14 and 17 (It
means, ‘not in personation’), and Philo contrasting divine
appearances with those of Angels. Leg. Alleg. iii. 62. On the
other hand, Theophilus on the text, ‘The voice of the Lord God
walking in the garden,’ speaks of the Word, ‘assuming the
person, πρόσωπον, of the Father,’ and ‘in the person of
God,’ ad Autol. ii. 22. the word not then having its
theological sense. by the patriarchs, gave the law, spoke by
the prophets, and at last, became man, and manifested His own Father to
all men, and reigns to never-ending ages. For Christ has taken no
recent dignity, but we have believed Him to be perfect from the first,
and like in all things to the Father ὅμοιον κατὰ
πάντα. Here again we
have a strong Semi-Arian or almost Catholic formula introduced by the
bye. Of course it admitted of evasion, but in its fulness it included
‘essence.’ [See above §8, note 1, and
Introd.].