doctrine which teaches that mankind are corrupt by nature, tends to promote ill-will, why
should not Dr. T.‘s doctrine tend to it as much? For he teaches us, that the generality of
mankind are very wicked, having made themselves so by their own free choice, without any
necessity: which is a way of becoming wicked, that renders men truly worthy of resentment;
but the other, not at all, even according to his own doctrine.
Another exclamation against this doctrine is, that it tends to hinder comfort and joy,
and to promote melancholy and gloominess of mind. 164
To which I shall briefly say, doubtless, supposing men are really become sinful, and so
exposed to the displeasure of God, by whatever means, if they once come to have their eyes
opened, and are not very stupid, the reflection on their case will tend to make them sorrowful;
and it is fit it should. Men, with whom this is the case, may well be filled with sorrow, till
they are sincerely willing to forsake their sins, and turn to God. But there is nothing in this
doctrine, that in the least stands in the way of comfort and exceeding joy, to such as find in
their hearts a sincere willingness wholly to forsake all sin, and give their hearts and whole
selves to Christ, and comply with the gospel-method of salvation by him.
Another thing objected, is, that to make men believe that wickedness belongs to their
very nature, tends to encourage them in sin, and plainly to lead them to all manner of iniquity;
because they are taught, that sin is natural, and therefore necessary and unavoidable. 165
But if this doctrine, which teaches that sin is natural to us, does also at the same time
teach us, that it is never the better, or less to be condemned, for its being natural, then it does
not at all encourage sin, any more than Dr. T.‘s doctrine encourages wickedness when it is
become inveterate; who teaches that such as by custom have contracted strong habits of sin,
are unable to help themselves. 166 And is it reasonable, to represent it as encouraging a man
in boldly neglecting and wilfully continuing in his disease, without seeking a cure, to tell
him of his disease, to show him that it is real and very fatal, and what he can never cure
himself of; yet withal directing him to a great Physician, who is sufficient for his restoration?
But for a more particular answer to what is objected against the doctrine of our natural im-
potence and inability, as being an encouragement to go on in sin, and a discouragement to
the use of all means for our help, I must for brevity refer the reader to what has been largely
written on this head in my discourse on the Freedom of the Will.
Our author is pleased to advance another notion, among others, by way of objection
against the doctrine of original sin: that if this doctrine be true, it would be unlawful to beget
children. He says, 167 “If natural generation be the means of unavoidably conveying all sin
164 Page 231, and some other places.
165 Page 139, and 259.
166 See his exposition on Rom. vii. p. 205 -220. But especially in his paraphrase and notes on the epistle.
167 Page 145.
1177
CHAPTER IV. Several other Objections answered.