We have now followed Hilary through his great
theory, in which we may safely say that no other theologian entirely
agrees, and which, where it is most original, diverges most widely from
the usual lines of Christian thought. Yet it nowhere contradicts
the accepted standards of belief; and if it errs it does so in
explanation, not in the statement of the truths which it undertakes to
explain. Hilary has the distinction of being the only one of his
contemporaries with the speculative genius to imagine this development
ending in the abolition of incongruity and in the restoration of the
full majesty of the Son and of man with Him
Förster, op. cit.. He saw that there must be such
a development, and if he was wrong in tracing its course, there is a
reverence and loyalty, a solidity of reasoning and steady grasp of the
problems under discussion, which save him from falling into mere
ingenuity or ostentation. Sometimes he may seem to be on the
verge of heresy; but in each case it will be found that, whether his
system be right or no, the place in it which he has found for an
argument used elsewhere in the interests of error is one where the
argument is powerless for evil. Sometimes—and this is the
most serious reproach that can be brought against him—it must
seem that his theology is abstract, moving in a region apart from the
facts of human life. It must be admitted that this is the case;
that though, as we shall presently see, Hilary had a clear sense of the
realities of temptation and sin and of the need of redemption, and has
expressed himself in these regards with the fervour and practical
wisdom of an earnest and experienced pastor, still these subjects lie
within the sphere of his feelings rather than of his thought. It
was not his fault that he lived in the days before St. Augustine, and
in the heat of an earlier controversy; and it is his conspicuous merit
that in his zeal for the Divinity of Christ he traced the Incarnation
back beyond the beginning of sin and found its motive in God’s
eternal purpose of uniting
man to Himself. He does not estimate the condescension of Christ
by the distance which separates the Sinless from the sinful. To
his wider thought sin is not the cause of that great sequence of Divine
acts of grace, but a disturbing factor which has modified its
course. The measure of the love of God in Christ is the infinity
He overpassed in uniting the Creator with the creature.