9. When he wrote his
treatises against Jovinian, and some one had raised objections to them,
he was informed of these objections by Domnio, that old man whose
memory we all revere; and in his answer to him
2949
he said that it was impossible that a
man like him should be in the wrong, since his knowledge extended to
everything that could be known: and he proceeded to enumerate the
various kinds of syllogisms, and the whole art of learning and of
writing (of course supposing that the man who found fault with him knew
nothing about such things). He then goes on thus:
2950
“It was foolish, it
appears, in me to think that I could not know all these things without
the philosophers, and to look upon the end of the stylus which strikes
out and corrects as better than the end with which we write. It was
useless for me it seems, to have translated
2951
the Commentaries of Alexander, and for my learned master to have
brought me into the knowledge of Logic through the
‘Introduction’ of Porphyry; and, putting aside humanistic
teachers, there was no reason why I should have had Gregory Nazianzen
and Didymus as my teachers in the Scriptures.”
This, you observe, is the man
who said to Christ, I have denied thee if ever I am found to possess or
to read the works of the heathen. He might, one would think, at all
events have left out Porphyry, who was Christ’s special enemy,
who endeavoured as far as in him lay to completely subvert the
Christian religion, but whom he now glories in having had as his
instructor in his Introduction to Logic. He cannot put in the plea that
he had learned these things at a former time: for, before his
conversion, he and I equally were wholly ignorant of the Greek language
and literature. All these things came after his oath, after that solemn
engagement had been made. It is of no use for us to argue in such a
case. It will at once be said to us: Man, you are wrong, God is not
mocked, and no syllogisms spun out of the books of Alexander will avail
with him. I think, my brother, it was an ill-omened event that you
submitted to the Introduction of Porphyry. Into what has that faithless
man introduced you? If it is into the place where he is now, that is
the place where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth; for there dwell
the apostate and the enemies of God; and perhaps the perjurers will go
there too.
2949
Ep. 1.
2950
Ep.
l. 1.
2951
Verti. Possibly used like Versare for ‘turning over the
leaves,’ ‘making constant use of.’