2. For he criticises, as a late innovation, the above-mentioned heresy which teaches that
the Saviour was a mere man, because they were attempting to magnify it as ancient.1737
Having given in his work many other arguments in refutation of their blasphemous falsehood,
he adds the following words:
3. “For they say that all the early teachers and the apostles received and taught what
they now declare, and that the truth of the Gospel was preserved until the times of Victor,
there is no reason to suppose that there were two separate parties. A few years later another attempt was made
in Rome to revive the old adoptionist Christology (essentially the same as that represented by Hermas early in
the second century), by a certain Artemon, against whom the Little Labyrinth,quoted in this chapter, was directed.
It is common to connect Artemon and his followers with the Theodotians; but, as Harnack remarks, it is plain
that they did not look upon themselves as the followers of the Theodoti (see below, note 15). We cannot tell,
however, in what respect their Christology differed from that of the latter, for we know very little about them.
They at any rate agreed with the Theodotians in denying the divinity of Christ. From the epistle of the synod of
Antioch (quoted below, in Bk. VII. chap. 30) we learn that Artemon was still living in the year 268, or thereabouts.
He seems, however to have accomplished little in Rome, and to have dropped into comparative obscurity some
time before this; at least, we hear nothing of him during all these years. In the controversy with Paul of Samosata
he was called the father of the latter (see below Bk. VII. chap. 30, §16), and thus acquired considerable celebrity
in the East, where his name became permanently connected with that of Paul as one of the leading heretics.
Whether Paul really learned his Christology from Artemon we do not know, but that it closely resembled that
of the latter there can be no doubt. He really reproduced the old adoptionist Christology of Hermas (as both
the Theodotians and Artemon had done), but modified it under the influence partly of Origen’s teachings, partly
of the Aristotelian method. For further particulars in regard to the Theodoti and Artemon, see the remaining
notes on this chapter. For an admirable discussion of the whole subject, see Harnack’s Dogmengeschichte, I. p.
573 sq. On the Little Labyrinth, see especially the Dict. of Christian Biog. III. p. 98.
1736 On Paul of Samosata, see below, Bk. VII. chap. 27, note 4.
1737 The Artemonites were certainly correct in maintaining that the adoptionism which they held was, at
least in its essential principles, an ancient thing, and their opponents were wrong in trying to deny it. It is the
Christology which Hermas represents, and early in the second century it was undoubtedly a widespread popular
belief. No one thought of questioning the orthodoxy of Hermas. The Christology of the Theodotians and of
Artemon was an innovation, however, in so far as it attempted to formulate in scientific terms and to treat
philosophically what had hitherto been only a popular belief. So soon as the logical conclusions were drawn,
and its consequences to the divinity of the Son were perceived, it began to be felt as heresy, but not until then.
593
Those who first advanced the Heresy of Artemon; their Manner of Life, and…