§4. He proceeds again to discuss the impassibility of the Lord’s generation; and the folly
of Eunomius, who says that the generated essence involves the appellation of Son, and again,
forgetting this, denies the relation of the Son to the Father: and herein he speaks of Circe and
of the mandrake poison.
We must, however, return to those who connect passion with the Divine generation,
and on this account deny that the Lord is truly begotten, in order to avoid the conception
of passion. To say that passion is absolutely linked with generation, and that on this account,
in order that the Divine nature may continue in purity beyond the reach of passion, we
ought to consider that the Son is alien to the idea of generation, may perhaps appear reas-
onable in the eyes of those who are easily deceived, but those who are instructed in the Divine
mysteries639 have an answer ready to hand, based upon admitted facts. For who knows not
that it is generation that leads us back to the true and blessed life, not being the same with
that which takes place “of blood and of the will of the flesh640,” in which are flux and change,
and gradual growth to perfection, and all else that we observe in our earthly generation: but
the other kind is believed to be from God, and heavenly, and, as the Gospel says, “from
above641,” which excludes the passions of flesh and blood? I presume that they both admit
the existence of this generation, and find no passion in it. Therefore not all generation is
naturally connected with passion, but the material generation is subject to passion, the im-
material pure from passion. What constrains him then to attribute to the incorruptible
generation of the Son what properly belongs to the flesh, and, by ridiculing the lower form
of generation with his unseemly physiology, to exclude the Son from affinity with the
Father? For if, even in our own case, it is generation that is the beginning of either life,—that
generation which is through the flesh of a life of passion, that which is spiritual of a life of
purity, (and no one who is in any sense numbered among Christians would contradict this
statement,)—how is it allowable to entertain the idea of passion in thinking of generation
as it concerns the incorruptible Nature? Let us moreover examine this point in addition to
those we have mentioned. If they disbelieve the passionless character of the Divine generation
on the ground of the passion that affects the flesh, let them also, from the same tokens,
(those, I mean, to be found in ourselves,) refuse to believe that God acts as a Maker without
passion. For if they judge of the Godhead by comparison of our own conditions, they must
not confess that God either begets or creates; for neither of these operations is exercised by
ourselves without passion. Let them therefore either separate from the Divine nature both
creation and generation, that they may guard the impassibility of God on either side, and
let them, that the Father may be kept safely beyond the range of passion, neither growing
639 That is, in the sacramental doctrine with regard to Holy Baptism.
640 S. John i. 13
641 S. John iii. 3, where ἄνωθεν may be interpreted either “from above” or as in A.V.
He proceeds again to discuss the impassibility of the Lord's generation; and the folly of Eunomius, who says that the generated essence involves the appellation of Son, and again, forgetting this, denies the relation of the Son to the Father: and herein he speaks of Circe and of the mandrake poison.
305
He proceeds again to discuss the impassibility of the Lord's generation;…