Then how will you make it fit
with what follows? For when Paul says, “Now the Lord is the
Spirit,” he goes on to say, “and where the Spirit of the
Lord is, there is liberty.” If then “the Lord is the
Spirit,” and “Spirit” means “essence,”
what are we to understand by “the essence of the essence”?
He speaks again of another Spirit of the Lord Who is the
Spirit,—that is to say, according to your interpretation, of
another essence. Therefore in your view the Apostle, when he
writes expressly of “the Lord the Spirit,” and of
“the Spirit of the Lord,” means nothing else than an
essence of an essence. Well, let Eunomius make what he likes of that
which is written; what we understand of the matter is as follows. The
Scripture, “given by inspiration of God,” as the Apostle
calls it, is the Scripture of the Holy Spirit, and its intention is the
profit of men. For “every scripture,” he says, “is
given by inspiration of God and is profitable”; and the profit is
varied and multiform, as the Apostle says—“for doctrine,
for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness 2 Tim. iii.
16..” Such a boon as this, however, is not
within any man’s reach to lay hold of, but the Divine intention
lies hid under the body of the Scripture, as it were under a veil, some
legislative enactment or some historical narrative being cast over the
truths that are contemplated by the mind. For this reason, then, the
Apostle tells us that those who look upon the body of the Scripture
have “a veil upon their heart 2 Cor. iii.
15.,” and are
not able to look upon the glory of the spiritual law, being hindered by
the veil that has been cast over the face of the law-giver. Wherefore
he says, “the letter killeth, but the Spirit giveth life,”
showing that often the obvious interpretation, if it be not taken
according to the proper sense, has an effect contrary to that life
which is indicated by the Spirit, seeing that this lays down for all
men the perfection of virtue in freedom from passion, while the history
contained in the writings sometimes embraces the exposition even of
facts incongruous, and is understood, so to say, to concur with the
passions of our nature, whereto if any one applies himself according to
the obvious sense, he will make the Scripture a doctrine of death.
Accordingly, he says that over the perceptive powers of the souls of
men who handle what is written in too corporeal a manner, the veil is
cast; but for those who turn their contemplation to that which is the
object of the intelligence, there is revealed, bared, as it were, of a
mask, the glory that underlies the letter. And that which is discovered
by this more exalted perception he says is the Lord, which is the
Spirit. For he says, “when it shall turn to the Lord the veil
shall be taken away: now the Lord is the Spirit 2 Cor. iii. 16,
17..” And in so saying he makes a
distinction of contrast between the lordship of the spirit and the
bondage of the letter; for as that which gives life is opposed to that
which kills, so he contrasts “the Lord” with bondage. And
that we may not be under any confusion when we are instructed
concerning the Holy Spirit (being led by the word “Lord” to
the thought of the Only-begotten), for this reason he guards the word
by repetition, both saying that “the Lord is the Spirit,”
and making further mention of “the Spirit of the Lord,”
that the supremacy of His Nature may be shown by the honour implied in
lordship, while at the same time he may avoid confusing in his argument
the individuality of His Person. For he who calls Him both
“Lord” and “Spirit of the Lord,” teaches us to
conceive of Him as a separate individual besides the Only-begotten;
just as elsewhere he speaks of “the Spirit of Christ Rom. viii. 9.,” employing fairly and in its mystic
sense this very term which is piously employed in the system of
doctrine according to the Gospel tradition. Thus we, the “most
miserable of all men,” being led onward by the Apostle in the
mysteries, pass from the letter that killeth to the Spirit that giveth
life, learning from Him Who was in Paradise initiated into the
unspeakable mysteries, that all things the Divine Scripture says are
utterances of the Holy Spirit. For “well did the Holy Spirit
prophesy Cf. Acts xxviii. 25.,”—this he says to the Jews
in Rome, introducing the words of Isaiah; and to the Hebrews, alleging
the authority of the Holy Spirit in the words, “wherefore as
saith the Holy Spirit Heb. iii. 7.,” he adduces
the words of the Psalm which are spoken at length in the person of God;
and from the Lord Himself we learn the same thing,—that David
declared the heavenly mysteries not “in” himself (that is,
not speaking according to human nature). For how could any one, being
but man, know the supercelestial converse of the Father with the Son?
But being “in the Spirit” he said that the Lord spoke to
the Lord those words which He has uttered. For if, He says,
“David in the Spirit calls him Lord, how is He then
his son S. Matt. xxii. 45; Cf. Ps. cx.
1.?” Thus it is by the power of the Spirit
that the holy men who are under Divine influence are inspired, and
every Scripture is for this reason said to be “given by
inspiration of God,” because it is the teaching of the Divine
afflatus. If the bodily veil of the words were removed, that which
remains is Lord and life and Spirit, according to the teaching of the
great Paul, and according to the words of the Gospel also. For Paul
declares that he who turns from the letter to the Spirit no longer
apprehends the bondage that slays, but the Lord which is the
life-giving Spirit; and the sublime Gospel says, “the words that
I speak are spirit and are life Cf.
S. John vi. 63,” as being
divested of the bodily veil. The idea, however, that “the
Spirit” is the essence of the Only-begotten, we shall leave to
our dreamers: or rather, we shall make use, ex abundanti, of
what they say, and arm the truth with the weapons of the adversary. For
it is allowable that the Egyptian should be spoiled by the Israelites,
and that we should make their wealth an ornament for ourselves. If the
essence of the Son is called “Spirit,” and God also is
Spirit, (for so the Gospel tells us S. John iv. 24), clearly the
essence of the Father is called “Spirit” also. But if it is
their peculiar argument that things which are introduced by different
names are different also in nature, the conclusion surely is, that
things which are named alike are not alien one from the other in nature
either. Since then, according to their account, the essence of the
Father and that of the Son are both called “Spirit,” hereby
is clearly proved the absence of any difference in essence. For a
little further on Eunomius says:—“Of those essences which
are divergent the appellations significant of essence are also surely
divergent, but where there is one and the same name, that which is
declared by the same appellation will surely be one
also”:—so that at all points “He that taketh the wise
in their own craftiness 1 Cor. iii. 19; cf. Job v.
13.” has turned the
long labours of our author, and the infinite toil spent on what he has
elaborated, to the establishment of the doctrine which we maintain. For
if God is in the Gospel called “Spirit,” and the essence of
the Only-begotten is maintained by Eunomius to be “Spirit,”
as there is no apparent difference in the one name as compared with the
other, neither, surely, will the things signified by the names be
mutually different in nature.