Sir William is of opinion that by what precedes in his
book he has “proved that for at least five centuries and a half
the Council of Nice remained rejected in the Western
Church.” I venture to think that the most he has proved is
that during that period of time he has been able to find fifteen
individuals who for one reason or another wrote rejecting that council,
that is to say three in a century, a number which does not seem quite
sufficient to make the foundation of so considerable a generalization
as “the Western Church.” The further conclusion of
Sir William, I think, every scholar will reject as simply preposterous,
viz.: “In fact the doctrine of the adoration of images [by
which he means the doctrine taught by the II. Council of Nice] was
never received in the West, except where the influence of the Roman See
was predominant” (p. 211).