I pass in silence his blasphemy
in reducing God the Only-begotten to a level with all created things,
and, in a word, allowing to the Son of God no higher honour than
theirs. Still, for the sake of my more intelligent hearers, I will here
give an instance of his insensate malice. Basil, he says, lends God the
primacy over all things by reference to the ages. What unintelligible
nonsense is this! Man is made God’s patron, and gives to God a
primacy owing to the ages! What is this vain flourish of baseless
expressions, seeing that our Master simply says that whatever in the
Divine essence transcends the measurable distances of the ages in
either direction is called by certain distinctive names, in the case of
Him Who, as saith the Apostle, hath neither beginning of days nor end
of life Heb. vii. 3., in order that the distinction of the
conception might be marked by distinction in the names. And yet on this
account Eunomius has the effrontery to write, that to call that which
is anterior to all beginning ungenerate, and again that which is
circumscribed by no limit, immortal and indestructible, is a bestowing
or lending on our part, and other nonsense of the kind. Moreover, he
says that we divide the ages into two parts, as if he had not read the
words he quoted, or as if he were addressing those who had forgotten
his own previous statements. For what says our Master? “If we
look at the time before the Creation, and if passing in thought through
the ages we reflect on the infinitude of the Eternal Life, we signify
the thought by the term ungenerate. And if we turn our thoughts to what
follows, and consider the being of God as extending beyond all ages, we
interpret the thought by the word endless or indestructible.”
Well, how does such an account sever the ages in twain, if by such
possible words and names we signify that eternity of God which is
equally observable from every point of view, in all things the same,
unbroken in continuity? For seeing that human life, moving from stage
to stage, advances in its progress from a beginning to an end, and our
life here is divided between that which is past and that which is
expected, so that the one is the subject of hope, the other of memory;
on this account, as, in relation to ourselves, we apprehend a past and
a future in this measurable extent, so also we apply the thought,
though incorrectly, to the transcendent nature of God; not of course
that God in His own existence leaves any interval behind, or passes on
afresh to something that lies before, but because our intellect can
only conceive things according to our nature, and measures the eternal
by a past and a future, where neither the past precludes the march of
thought to the illimitable and infinite, nor the future tells us of any
pause or limit of His endless life. If, then, it is thus that we think
and speak, why does he keep taunting us with dividing the ages? Unless,
indeed, Eunomius would maintain that Holy Scripture does so too,
signifying as it does by the same idea the infinity of the Divine
existence; David, for example, making mention of the “kingdom
from everlasting,” and Moses, speaking of the kingdom of God as
“extending beyond all ages,” so that we are taught by both
that every duration conceivable is environed by the Divine nature,
bounded on all sides by the infinity of Him Who holds the universe in
His embrace. For Moses, looking to the future, says that “He
reigneth from generation to generation for evermore.” And great
David, turning his thought backward to the past, says, “God is
our King before the ages Cf. Ps. xliv. 4, and
xlviii. 14, with lxxiv. 12.,” and again,
“God, Who was before the ages, shall hear us.” But
Eunomius, in his cleverness taking leave of such guides as these, says
that we talk of the life that is without beginning as one, and of that
which is without end as quite another, and again, of diversities of
sundry ages, effecting by their own diversity a separation in our idea
of God. But that our controversy may not grow to a tedious length, we
will add, without criticism or comment, the outcome of Eunomius’
labours on the subject, well fitted as they are by his industry
displayed in the cause of error to render the truth yet more evident to
the eyes of the discerning.