Chapter 8.—Concerning the Interpretations, Consisting of Natural Explanations, Which
the Pagan Teachers Attempt to Show for Their Gods.
But all these things, they say, have certain physical, that is, natural interpretations,
showing their natural meaning; as though in this disputation we were seeking physics and
not theology, which is the account, not of nature, but of God. For although He who is the
true God is God, not by opinion, but by nature, nevertheless all nature is not God; for there
is certainly a nature of man, of a beast, of a tree, of a stone,—none of which is God. For if,
when the question is concerning the mother of the gods, that from which the whole system
of interpretation starts certainly is, that the mother of the gods is the earth, why do we make
further inquiry? why do we carry our investigation through all the rest of it? What can more
manifestly favor them who say that all those gods were men? For they are earth-born in the
sense that the earth is their mother. But in the true theology the earth is the work, not the
mother, of God. But in whatever way their sacred rites may be interpreted, and whatever
reference they may have to the nature of things, it is not according to nature, but contrary
to nature, that men should be effeminates. This disease, this crime, this abomination, has
a recognized place among those sacred things, though even depraved men will scarcely be
compelled by torments to confess they are guilty of it. Again, if these sacred rites, which
are proved to be fouler than scenic abominations, are excused and justified on the ground
that they have their own interpretations, by which they are shown to symbolize the nature
of things, why are not the poetical things in like manner excused and justified? For many
have interpreted even these in like fashion, to such a degree that even that which they say
is the most monstrous and most horrible,—namely, that Saturn devoured his own chil-
dren,—has been interpreted by some of them to mean that length of time, which is signified
by the name of Saturn, consumes whatever it begets; or that, as the same Varro thinks, Saturn
belongs to seeds which fall back again into the earth from whence they spring. And so one
interprets it in one way, and one in another. And the same is to be said of all the rest of this
theology.
117
And, nevertheless, it is called the fabulous theology, and is censured, cast off, rejected,
together with all such interpretations belonging to it. And not only by the natural theology,
which is that of the philosophers, but also by this civil theology, concerning which we are
speaking, which is asserted to pertain to cities and peoples, it is judged worthy of repudiation,
because it has invented unworthy things concerning the gods. Of which, I wot, this is the
secret: that those most acute and learned men, by whom those things were written, under-
stood that both theologies ought to be rejected,—to wit, both that fabulous and this civil
one,—but the former they dared to reject, the latter they dared not; the former they set forth
to be censured, the latter they showed to be very like it; not that it might be chosen to be
held in preference to the other, but that it might be understood to be worthy of being rejected
together with it. And thus, without danger to those who feared to censure the civil theology,
Concerning the Interpretations, Consisting of Natural Explanations, Which the Pagan Teachers Attempt to Show for Their Gods.
274
Concerning the Interpretations, Consisting of Natural Explanations, Which…