Boos 1.] . ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 51
The reasons why he chose to-do it in this way, and did
not choose to do it in that, are unknown, being involved
in so great obscurity, and comprehensible by scarcely any;
but these you might perhaps have understood if you were
not already prepared not to understand, and were not shaping
your course to brave unbelief, before that was explained to
you which you sought to know and to hear.
62. But [you will say] he was cut off by death as men
are. Not [Christ] himself; for it is impossible either that
death should befall what is divine, or that that should waste
away and disappear in death which is one [in its substance],
and not compounded, nor formed by bringing together any
parts. Who, then [you ask], was seen hanging on the cross?
Who dead? The human form, [I reply], which he had
put on, and which he bore about with him. It is a tale
passing belief, [you say], and wrapt in dark obscurity; if
you will, it is not dark, and [is] established by a very close
analogy.’ If the Sibyl, when she was uttering and pouring
forth her prophecies and oracular responses, was filled, as you
say, with Apollo’s power, had been cut down and slain by
impious robbers, would Apollo be said to have been slain in
her? If Bacis,’ if Helenus, Marcius,? and other soothsayers,
had been in like manner robbed of life and light when raving
as inspired, would any one say that those who, speaking by
1 So the s., followed by Hildebrand and Oehler, reads and punctu-
ates quis mortuus? homo, for which all edd. read mortuus est? ** Who
died?"
? Here, as in the whole diseussion in the second book on the origin
and nature of the soul, the opinions expressed are Gnostic, Cerinthus
saying more precisely that Christ having descended from heaven in the
form of a dove, dwelt in the body of Jesus during his life, but removed
from it before the crucifixion.
? So the ws. by changing a single letter, with LB. and others, simili-
tudine proxim-a (MS. 0) constitutum ; while the first ed., Gelenius, Can-
terus, Ursinus, Orelli, and others, read*-dini prorime—** settled very
elosely to analogy."
* In the original latronibus; here, as in the next chapter, used loosely
to denote lawless men.
5 So emended by Mercerus for the ws, vatis.
$ So read in the Ms.—not -tius, as in LB. and Orelli.