Yet after admitting that soul
and body are born together and attaching such importance to the
‘physical basis’ of life and thought, the influence of his
master, or else his own uncontrollable idealism, carries him away again
in the opposite direction. After reading words in his treatise which
Locke might have written we come upon others which are exactly the
teaching of Berkeley. There is a passage in the De Animâ et
Resurrectione where he deals with the question how an intelligent
Being could have created matter, which is neither intelligent or
intelligible. But what if matter is only a concourse of
qualities, ἔννοιαι, or ψιλὰ
νοήματα as
he elsewhere calls them? Then there would be no difficulty in
understanding the manner of creation. But even about this we can say so
much, i.e. that not one of those things which we attribute to body is
itself body: neither figure, nor colour, nor weight, nor extension, nor
quantity, nor any other qualifying notion whatever: but every one of
them is a thought: it is the combination of them all into a
single whole that constitutes body. Seeing, then, that these
several
qualifications which complete the particular body are grasped by
thought alone, and not by sense, and that the Deity is a thinking
being, what trouble can it be to such a thinking agent to produce the
thoughts whose mutual combination generate for us the substance
of that body? and in the treatise, De Hom. Opif., c. 24, the
intelligible φύσις is said to
produce the intelligible δυνάμεις, and the concourse of these δυνάμεις brings into being the material nature. The body itself, he
repeats (contra Fatum, p. 67), is not a real substance; it is a
soulless, unsubstantial thing. The only real creation is that of
spirits. Even Origen did not go so far as that Matter with him, though
it exists by concomitance and not by itself, nevertheless really
exists. He avoided a rock upon which Gregory runs; for with Gregory not
only matter but created spirit as well vanish in idealism. There remain
with him only the νοούμενα and God.