See above, IV. 9.
There is some doubt as to what the practice was which Gregory had
forbidden in his former epistle but now allows. In Ep. IX. he had
said, “Episcopi baptizatos infantes signare bis in fronte
chrismate non præsumant; sed presbyteri baptizandos ungant in
pectore, ut episcopi postmodum ungere debeant in fronte.”
There is obvious reference here to the two unctions, before and after
baptism. The first, in preparation for baptism, was with simple
oil, on the breast and other parts of the body, and was administered by
presbyters both in the East and West: the second for confirmation
after baptism, was with chrism (a mixture of oil and balsam), on the
forehead, and in the Eastern Churches might be, as it still is,
administered immediately after baptism by the baptizing presbyter, but
in the West was usually reserved for the bishop in person. It
would seem that in Sardinia the Eastern usage had been followed with
regard to the presbyter signing the baptized child on the forehead with
chrism immediately after baptism, but that it had been also customary
for the bishop afterward to repeat the rite (“signare bis in
fronte chrismate”). Such repetition Gregory, in Ep. IX.,
appears to forbid in cases where the presbyter had already administered
the rite; but, in the second clause of the sentence, he directs that
the Western usage should thenceforth be observed: the presbyter
who baptized was to anoint on the breast before the baptism; but the
bishop, and he alone, on the forehead with chrism afterwards.
Such being the most obvious meaning of what is said in Ep. IX. the
equally obvious meaning of the concession in Ep. XXVI. would be
allowance for presbyters in the absence of bishops, to confirm with
chrism after baptism, according to the Eastern usage, but for the fact
that the expression now used is not baptizatos, but
baptizandos. Hence one opinion is that all that is
here allowed to presbyters is the anointing of the forehead with
chrism, as well as the breast with oil, previously to baptism;
in which case of course it would not be confirmation. But it
seems more likely that the intention was to allow presbyters to
administer confirmation in the absence of bishops, the term
baptizandos being used loosely to denote candidates for
baptism. The fact that it is only where bishops could not be had
(ubi desunt episcopi) that the practice is allowed adds
probability to this view; and also his saying that in his previous
prohibition he had been following the ancient custom of the Roman
Church, which was to reserve the signing the forehead with chrism after
baptism, i.e. confirmation, to the bishop. Innocent I.
(Ep. i. ad. Decent. c. iii.) lays down the rule thus;
“Presbyteris, qui, seu extra episcopum seu pæesente
episcopo, baptizant, chrismate baptizatos ungere licet, sed quod ab
episcopo fuerit consecratum; non tamen frontem ex eodem oleo signare,
quod solis debetur episcopis, quum tradunt Spiritum Sanctum
Paracletum.” Here, we observe, the usage of the Roman
Church allows the baptizing presbyter to anoint with chrism after
baptism, only not therewith to sign the forehead for actual
confirmation; and this is still the Roman usage. It should be
observed further that in all cases, in the East as well in the West,
confirmation was regarded as belonging peculiarly to the Bishop’s
office, the chrism used having always been consecrated by him, though
it might be applied by presbyters: and thus Gregory, in allowing
presbyters to administer the rite in Sardinia, would not regard any
essential principle of Church order as being infringed. He only
shews the same wise liberality as we find evidence of in other cases,
allowing varieties of usage in various churches, where no important
principle seemed to be involved. Thus he approves of single
instead of triune immersion in baptism being practised in Spain (I.
43), and bids Augustine in England adopt according to his discretion
the customs of other Churches (XI. 64). With regard to the
essential form of confirmation recognized in the time of
Gregory, it appears evidently from these epistles to have been
unction, and not mere imposition of hands. It is also
evident that it was administered, as in the East now, to infants; cf.
XIII. 18, where the phrase is “ad consignandos
imantes.”