3. At the outset before I defend my version I wish to
ask those persons who confound wisdom with cunning, some few questions.
Where did you get your copy of the letter? Who gave it to you? How have
you the effrontery to bring forward what you have procured by fraud?
What place of safety will be left us if we cannot conceal our secrets
even within our own walls and our own writing-desks? Were I to press
such a charge against you before a legal tribunal, I could make you
amenable to the laws which even in fiscal cases appoint penalties for
meddlesome informers and condemn the traitor even while they accept his
treachery. For though they welcome the profit which the information
gives them, they disapprove the motive which actuates the informer. A
little while ago a man of consular rank named Hesychius (against whom
the patriarch Gamaliel waged an implacable war) was condemned to death
by the emperor Theodosius simply because he had laid hold of imperial
papers through a secretary whom he had tempted. We read also in old
histories Livy v. 27. that the schoolmaster who betrayed
the children of the Faliscans was sent back to his boys and handed over
to them in bonds, the Roman people refusing to accept a dishonourable
victory. When Pyrrhus king of Epirus was lying in his camp ill from the
effects of a wound, his physician offered to poison him, but Fabricius
thinking it shame that the king should die by treachery sent the
traitor back in chains to his master, refusing to sanction crime even
when its victim was an enemy. Plutarch, Life of
Pyrrhus. A principle which
the laws uphold, which is maintained by enemies, which warfare and the
sword fail to violate, has hitherto been held unquestioned among the
monks and priests of Christ. And can any one of them presume now,
knitting his brow and snapping his fingers, Jerome constantly
speaks of Rufinus in this way. See Letter CXXV. 18 and Apol. c. Ruf. I.
13, 32.
to spend his breath in saying: “What if he did use bribes or
other inducements! he did what suited his purpose.” A strange
plea truly to defend a fraud as though robbers, thieves, and pirates
did not do the same. Certainly, when Annas and Caiaphas led hapless
Judas astray, they only did what they believed to be expedient for
themselves.