Must we then enter minutely into
this, and laboriously refute all his invectives by showing that Basil
was not this monster of his imagination? If we did this, contentedly
proving the absence of anything vile and criminal in him, we should
seem to join in insulting one who was a ‘bright particular
star’ to his generation. But I remember how with that divine
voice of his he quoted the prophet Jeremiah iii.
3. with regard to
him, comparing him to a shameless woman who casts her own reproaches on
the chaste. For whom do these reasonings of his proclaim to be
truth’s enemy and in arms against public opinion? Who is it who
begs the readers of his book not ‘to look to the numbers of those
who profess a belief, or to mere tradition, or to let their judgment be
biassed so as to consider as trustworthy what is only suspected to be
the stronger side?’ Can one and the same man write like this, and
then make those charges, scheming that his readers should follow his
own novelties at the very moment that he is abusing others for opposing
themselves to the general belief? As for ‘brazening out facts
which give him the lie, and men’s censure,’ I leave the
reader to judge to whom this applies; whether to one who by a most
careful self-restraint made sobriety and quietness and perfect purity
the rule of his own life as well as that of his entourage, or to one
who advised that nature should not be molested when it is her pleasure
to advance through the appetites of the body, not to thwart indulgence,
nor to be so particular as that in the training of our life; but that a
self-chosen faith should be considered sufficient for a man to attain
perfection. If he denies that this is his teaching, I and any
right-minded person would rejoice if he were telling the truth in such
a denial. But his genuine followers will not allow him to produce such
a denial, or their leading principles would be gone, and the platform
of those who for this reason embrace his tenets would fall to pieces.
As for shameless indifference to human censure, you may look at his
youth or his after life, and you would find him in both open to this
reproach. The two men’s lives, whether in youth or manhood, tell
a widely-different tale.