Chapter
XXII.—The Same Conclusion Supported by the Transfiguration.
Marcion Inconsistent in Associating with Christ in Glory Two Such
Eminent Servants of the Creator as Moses and Elijah. St. Peter’s
Ignorance Accounted for on Montanist Principle.
You ought to be very much ashamed of
yourself on this account too, for
permitting him to appear on the retired mountain in the company of
Moses and Elias,
4319
whom he had come to
destroy. This, to be sure,
4320
was what he wished
to be understood as the meaning of that voice from heaven: “This
is my beloved Son, hear Him”
4321
—
Him
, that is, not Moses or
Elias any longer. The voice alone, therefore, was enough, without the
display of Moses and Elias; for, by expressly mentioning whom they were
to hear, he must have forbidden all
4322
others from
being heard. Or else, did he mean that Isaiah and Jeremiah and the
others whom he did not exhibit were to be heard, since he prohibited
those whom he did display? Now, even if their presence was necessary,
they surely should not be represented as conversing together, which is
a sign of familiarity; nor as associated in glory with him, for this
indicates respect and graciousness; but they should be shown in some
slough
4323
as a sure token of
their ruin, or even in that darkness of the Creator which Christ was
sent to disperse, far removed from the glory of Him who was about to
sever their words and writings from His gospel. This, then, is
the way
4324
how he demonstrates
them to be aliens,
4325
even by keeping
them in his own company! This is how he shows they ought to be
relinquished: he associates them with himself instead! This is how he
destroys them: he irradiates them with his glory! How would their own
Christ act? I suppose He would have imitated the frowardness (of
heresy),
4326
and revealed them
just as Marcion’s Christ was bound to do, or at least as having
with Him any others rather than His own prophets! But what could so
well befit the Creator’s Christ, as to manifest Him in the
company of His own foreannouncers?
4327
—to let
Him be seen with those to whom He had appeared in revelations?—to
let Him be speaking with those who had spoken of Him?—to share
His glory with those by whom He used to be called the Lord of glory;
even with those chief servants of His, one of whom was once the
moulder
4328
of His people, the
other afterwards the reformer
4329
thereof; one the
initiator of the Old Testament, the other the consummator
4330
of the New? Well therefore does Peter, when
recognizing the companions of his Christ in their indissoluble
connection with Him, suggest an expedient: “It is good for us to
be here” (good: that evidently means to be where Moses and Elias
are); “and let us make three tabernacles, one for Thee, and one
for Moses, and one for Elias. But he knew not what he
said.”
4331
How knew not?
Was his ignorance the result of simple error? Or was it on the
principle which we maintain
4332
in the cause of the
new prophecy,
4333
that to grace
ecstasy or rapture
4334
is incident. For
when a man is rapt in the Spirit, especially when he beholds the glory
of God, or when God speaks through him, he necessarily loses his
sensation,
4335
because he is
overshadowed with the power of God,—a point concerning which
there is a question between us and the carnally-minded.
4336
Now, it is no difficult matter to prove the
rapture
4337
of Peter. For how
could he have known Moses and Elias, except (by being) in the Spirit?
People could not have had their images, or statues, or likenesses; for
that the law forbade. How, if it were not that he had seen them in the
Spirit? And therefore, because it was in the Spirit that he had now
spoken, and not in his natural senses, he could not know what he had
said. But if, on the other hand,
4338
he was thus
ignorant, because he erroneously supposed that (Jesus) was their
Christ, it is then evident that Peter, when previously asked by Christ,
“Whom they thought Him to be,” meant the Creator’s
Christ, when he answered, “Thou art the Christ;” because if
he had been then aware that He belonged to the rival god, he would not
have made a mistake here. But if he was in error here because of his
previous erroneous opinion,
4339
then you may be
sure that up to that very day no new divinity had been revealed by
Christ, and that Peter had so far made no mistake, because hitherto
Christ had revealed nothing of the kind; and that Christ accordingly
was not to be regarded as belonging to any other
than the Creator, whose entire
dispensation
4340
he, in fact, here
described. He selects from His disciples three witnesses of the
impending vision and voice. And this is just the way of the Creator.
“In the mouth of three witnesses,” says He, “shall
every word be established.”
4341
He withdraws
to a mountain. In the nature of the place I see much meaning. For the
Creator had originally formed His ancient people on a mountain both
with visible glory and His voice. It was only right that the New
Testament should be attested
4342
on such an elevated
spot
4343
as that whereon the Old Testament had been
composed;
4344
under a like
covering of cloud also, which nobody will doubt, was condensed out of
the Creator’s air. Unless, indeed, he
4345
had brought down his own clouds thither, because he had himself forced
his way through the Creator’s heaven;
4346
or
else it was only a precarious cloud,
4347
as it were, of
the Creator which he used. On the present (as also on the
former)
4348
occasion,
therefore, the cloud was not silent; but there was the accustomed voice
from heaven, and the Father’s testimony to the Son; precisely as
in the first Psalm He had said, “Thou art my Son, today have I
begotten thee.”
4349
By the mouth of
Isaiah also He had asked concerning Him, “Who is there among you
that feareth God? Let him hear the voice of His Son.”
4350
When therefore He here presents Him with the
words, “This is my (beloved) Son,” this clause is of course
understood, “whom I have promised.” For if He once
promised, and then afterwards says, “This is He,” it is
suitable conduct for one who accomplishes His purpose
4351
that He should utter His voice in proof of
the promise which He had formerly made; but unsuitable in one who is
amenable to the retort, Can you, indeed, have a right to say,
“This is my son,” concerning whom you have given us no
previous information,
4352
any more than you
have favoured us with a revelation about your own prior existence?
“Hear ye Him,” therefore, whom from the beginning (the
Creator) had declared entitled to be heard in the name of a prophet,
since it was as a prophet that He had to be regarded by the people.
“A prophet,” says Moses, “shall the Lord your God
raise up unto you, of your sons” (that is, of course, after a
carnal descent
4353
); “unto Him
shall ye hearken, as unto me.”
4354
“Every
one who will not hearken unto Him, his soul
4355
shall be cut off from amongst his people.”
4356
So also Isaiah: “Who is there among
you that feareth God? Let him hear the voice of His
Son.”
4357
This voice the
Father was going Himself to recommend. For, says he,
4358
He establishes the words of His Son, when He
says, “This is my beloved Son, hear ye Him.” Therefore,
even if there be made a transfer of the obedient “hearing”
from Moses and Elias to
4359
Christ, it is still
not from another God, or to another Christ; but from
4360
the Creator to His Christ, in consequence of
the departure of the old covenant and the supervening of the new.
“Not an ambassador, nor an angel, but He Himself,” says
Isaiah, “shall save them;”
4361
for it is He Himself who is now declaring and fulfilling the law and
the prophets. The Father gave to the Son new disciples,
4362
after that Moses and Elias had been
exhibited along with Him in the honour of His glory, and had then been
dismissed as having fully discharged their duty and office, for the
express purpose of affirming for Marcion’s information the fact
that Moses and Elias had a share in even the glory of Christ. But we
have the entire structure
4363
of this same vision
in Habakkuk also, where the Spirit in the person of some
4364
of the apostles says, “O Lord, I have
heard Thy speech, and was afraid.” What speech was this, other
than the words of the voice from heaven, This is my beloved Son, hear
ye Him? “I considered thy works, and was astonished.” When
could this have better happened than when Peter, on seeing His glory,
knew not what he was saying? “In the midst of the two Thou shalt
be known”—even Moses and
Elias.
4365
These likewise
did Zechariah see under the figure of the two olive trees and olive
branches.
4366
For these are they
of whom he says, “They are the two anointed ones, that stand by
the Lord of the whole earth.” And again Habakkuk says, “His
glory covered the heavens” (that is, with that cloud), “and
His splendour shall be like the light—even the light, wherewith
His very raiment glistened.” And if we would make mention
of
4367
the promise to Moses, we shall find it
accomplished here. For when Moses desired to see the Lord, saying,
“If therefore I have found grace in Thy sight, manifest Thyself
to me, that I may see Thee distinctly,”
4368
the sight which he desired to have was of that condition which he was
to assume as man, and which as a prophet he knew was to occur.
Respecting the
face
of God, however, he had already heard,
“No man shall see me, and live.” “This thing,”
said He, “which thou hast spoken, will I do unto
thee.” Then Moses said, “Show me Thy
glory.” And the Lord, with like reference to the future,
replied, “I will pass before thee in my glory,” etc. Then
at the last He says, “And then thou shalt see my
back.”
4369
Not loins, or
calves of the legs, did he want to behold, but the glory which was to
be revealed in the latter days.
4370
He had
promised that He would make Himself thus face to face visible to him,
when He said to Aaron, “If there shall be a prophet among you, I
will make myself known to him by vision, and by vision will I speak
with him; but not so is my manner to Moses; with
him
will I
speak mouth to mouth, even apparently” (that is to say, in the
form of man which He was to assume), “and not in dark
speeches.”
4371
Now, although
Marcion has denied
4372
that he is here
represented as speaking with the Lord, but only as standing, yet,
inasmuch as he stood “mouth to mouth,” he must also have
stood “face to face”
with him
, to use his
words,
4373
not far from him,
in His very glory—not to say,
4374
in His
presence. And with this glory he went away enlightened from Christ,
just as he used to do from the Creator; as
then
to dazzle the
eyes of the children of Israel, so
now
to smite those of the
blinded Marcion, who has failed to see how this argument also makes
against him.
4319
Luke ix. 28–36
.
4320
Scilicet, in ironical
allusion to a Marcionite opinion.
4321
Luke ix. 35
.
4322
Quoscunque.
4323
In sordibus
aliquibus.
4324
Sic.
4325
To belong to another
god.
4326
Secundum
perversitatem.
4327
Prædicatores.
4328
Informator, Moses, as
having organized the nation.
4329
Reformator, Elias, the
great prophet.
4330
It was a primitive
opinion in the Church that Elijah was to come, with Enoch, at the end
of the world. See
De Anima
, chap. xxxv. and l.; also
Irenæus,
De Hæres
. v. 5. [Vol. I. 530.]
4331
Luke ix. 33
.
4332
This Tertullian seems
to have done in his treatise
De Ecstasi
, which is mentioned by
St. Jerome—see his
Catalogus Scriptt. Eccles.
(in
Tertulliano); and by Nicephorus,
Hist. Eccles.
iv. 22, 34.
On this subject of ecstasy, Tertullian has some observations in
De
Anima
, chap. xxi. and xlv. (Rigalt. and Oehler.)
4333
[Elucidation VII.]
4334
Amentiam.
4335
Excidat sensu.
4336
He calls those the
carnally-minded (“psychicos”) who thought that ecstatic
raptures and revelations had ceased in the church. The term
arises from a perverse application of
1 Cor. ii. 14
:
ψυχικὸς δὲ
ἄνθρωπος οὐ
δέχεται τὰ
τοῦ
Πνεύματος
τοῦ Θεοῦ
. In opposition to
the wild fanaticism of Montanus, into which Tertullian strangely fell,
the Catholics believed that the true prophets, who were filled with the
Spirit of God, discharged their prophetic functions with a quiet and
tranquil mind. See the anonymous author,
Contra Cataphrygas
, in
Eusebius,
Hist. Eccl
. v. 17; Epiphanius,
Hæres
. 48.
See also Routh,
Rell. Sacræ
, i. p. 100; and Bp. Kaye,
On the Writings of Tertullian
, edit. 3, pp. 27–36.
(Munter’s
Primord. Eccles. Afric.
p. 138, quoted by
Oehler.)
4337
Amentiam.
4338
Ceterum.
4339
According to the
hypothesis.
4340
Totum ordinem, in the
three periods represented by Moses, and Elijah, and Christ.
4341
Compare
Deut. xix. 15 with Luke ix. 28
.
4342
Consignari.
4343
In eo suggestu.
4344
Conscriptum
fuerat.
4345
Marcion’s
god.
4346
Compare above, book i.
chap. 15, and book iv. chap. 7.
4347
Precario. This
word is used in book v. chap. xii. to describe the
transitoriness
of the Creator’s paradise and
world.
4348
Nec nunc.
4349
Ps. ii. 7
.
4350
Isa. l. 10
, according to the Septuagint.
4351
Ejus est
exhibentis.
4352
Non præmisisti.
Oehler suggests
promisisti
, “have given us no
promise.”
4353
Censum: Some read
sensum
, “sense.”
4354
Deut. xviii. 15
.
4355
Anima: life.
4356
Deut. xviii. 19
.
4357
Isa. l. 10
.
4358
Tertullian, by
introducing this statement with an “
inquit
,” seems
to make a quotation of it; but it is only a comment on the actual
quotations. Tertullian’s invariable object in this argument is to
match some event or word pertaining to the Christ of the New Testament
with some declaration of the Old Testament. In this instance the
approving words of God upon the mount are in
Heb. i. 5
applied to the Son, while in
Ps. ii. 7
the Son applies them to Himself. Compare
the
Adversus Praxean
, chap. xix. (Fr. Junius and Oehler). It is,
however, more likely that Tertullian really means to quote
Isa. xliv. 26
, “that confirmeth the word of His
servant,” which Tertullian reads, “Sistens verba filii
sui,” the Septuagint being,
Καὶ ἰστῶν
ῥῆμα παιδὸς
αὐτοῦ
.
4359
In Christo.
In
with an ablative is often used by our author for
in
with an accusative.
4360
Or perhaps “by
the Creator.”
4361
Isa. lxiii. 9
, according to the Septuagint; only he
reads
faciet
for aorist
ἔσωσεν
.
4362
A Marcionite
position.
4363
Habitum.
4364
Interdum.
4365
Hab. iii. 2
, according to the Septuagint. St.
Augustine similarly applied this passage,
De Civit. Dei
, xviii.
32.
4366
Zech. iv. 3, 14
.
4367
Commemoremur: be
reminded, or call to mind.
4368
Cognoscenter:
γνωστῶς
, “so as
to know Thee.”
4369
See
Ex. xxxiii. 13–23
.
4370
Posterioribus
temporibus
. [The awful ribaldry of Voltaire upon this glorious
revelation is based upon the Vulgate reading of
Exod. xxxiii. 23
, needlessly transferred to our Version,
but corrected by the late Revisers.]
4371
Num. xii. 6–8
.
4372
Noluit.
4373
It is difficult to see
what this
inquit
means.
4374
Nedum.