Yet no one would imagine that
here the poet, any more than S. Paul in Ephes. vi. 24 (see p. 343, note
3), meant celibacy per se. But it may be asked, how came Gregory
to use the word Virginity at all for pure disengagement of soul? The
answer seems to be, that he was very fond of metaphors and elaborate
comparisons, ever since the days that he was a student of Rhetoric;
this treatise itself is full of similes from nature, and they are not
so much poetry or rhetoric, as necessary means of bringing his meaning
vividly before readers. Virginity, then, is one of these bold and
telling figures; and in his hands it is a very suggestive metaphor;
though certainly at times it runs away with him. The accusation, then,
that when he identifies Piety and Virginity, he makes the former
consist in a mere externality, is unfounded. He uses the one word for
the other without apprising us that it is a metaphor, and he omits to
give any dietary rules by which this virginity is secured. Therefore he
appears to mean celibacy. But on the other hand no arguments can
be drawn from this treatise against the monastic life; only Gregory is
busied with other matters. Rather, if the actual marriages of his time
are such as he describes, it is a silent witness to the reasonableness,
if not to the necessity, of such a life within the church. For this
view of virginity as solving the question of Gregory’s supposed
marriage, see Prolegomena, p. 3.