SECT. XIII.
Concerning Judas’s partaking of the Lord’s supper.
I think, we have a remarkable instance of tergiversation, in what Mr. W. says in support
of the argument from Judas’s partaking of the Lord’s supper. By those on his side of the
question, it is insisted upon, as a clear evidence of its being lawful for unsanctified men to
come to the Lord’s table, that Christ gave the Lord’s supper to Judas, when he knew he was
unsanctified. In answer to which I showed, that this is just as much against their own prin-
ciples, as mine; because Christ knew as perfectly that he was not morally sincere, as that he
was not graciously sincere; and they themselves hold, that it is not lawful for such as are not
morally sincere, to partake. Mr. W. ridicules this, as very impertinent and strange; because
Christ did not know this as head of the visible church, but only as omniscient God and
searcher of hearts. And what does this argue? Only, that although Judas was really not fit
to come, yet, inasmuch as Christ, acting as king of the visible church, did not know it, he
might admit him: but not, that it was lawful for Judas himself to come, who knew his own
heart in this matter, and knew his own perfidiousness and treachery; Mr. W. denies, that it
is lawful for such to come, as have no moral sincerity. So that here the question is changed;
from, who may lawfully come, to who may lawfully be admitted? Mr. W. abundantly insists,
that the question is not, who shall be admitted? but, who way lawfully come? Not, whether
it be lawful to admit those who have not a visibility of saintship, or do not appear to be true
saints? but whether those who are not true saints, may lawfully partake? And this he insists
upon in his discourse on this very argument, (p. 104, c. d.) And to prove this latter point,
viz. That those, who are not real saints, may lawfully come, the instance of Judas’s coming
to the Lord’s supper is produced as an undeniable evidence. But when it is answered, that
the argument does not prove this, any more than that the morally insincere may lawfully
523
come; because Judas was morally insincere: then Mr. W. (p. 106.) to shelter himself, evidently
changes the question, at once, to that which he had so much exclaimed against as not the
question. Now, to serve his turn, the question is not, whether Judas might lawfully come?
but, whether Christ might lawfully admit him, acting on a public visibility? And he makes
an occasion to cry out against me, as talking strangely, and soon forgetting that I had said,
Christ in this matter did not act as searcher of hearts. Whereas, let the question be what it
will, the argument from Judas’s partaking, (should the fact be supposed,) if it proves any
thing relating to the matter, is perfectly, and in every respect, against the one, just as it is
against the other. It the question be about profession and visibility to others, and who others
may lawfully admit, then Judas’s being admitted, (if he was admitted,) no more proves, that
men may be admitted without a visibility and profession of godliness, than without a visib-
ility of moral sincerity. For it no more appears, that he was without a profession and visibility
of the former, than of the latter. But if the question is not about visibility to others, or who
others may admit, but who may lawfully come, then Judas’s coming no more proves, that a
SECTION XIII. Of Judas's communicating.
2010
SECTION XIII. Of Judas's communicating.