“When these actions, in
keeping with their course of life, and the impious enterprise which had
been long concealed, became tardily known to us, we unanimously ejected
them from the Church which worships the divinity of Christ. They then
ran hither and thither to form cabals against us, even addressing
themselves to our fellow-ministers who were of one mind with us, under
the pretence of seeking peace and unity with them, but in truth
endeavouring by means of fair words, to sweep some among them away into
their own disease. They ask them to write a wordy letter, and then read
the contents to those whom they have deceived, in order that they may
not retract, but be confirmed in their impiety, by finding that bishops
agree with and support their views. They make no acknowledgment of the
evil doctrines and practices for which they have been expelled by us,
but they either impart them without comment, or carry on the deception
by fallacies and forgeries. Thus concealing their destructive doctrine
by persuasive and meanly truckling language, they catch the unwary, and
lose no opportunity of calumniating our religion. Hence it arises that
several have been led to sign their letter, and to receive them into
communion, a proceeding on the part of our fellow-ministers which I
consider highly reprehensible; for they thus not only disobey the
apostolical rule, but even help to inflame their diabolical action
against Christ. It is on this account, beloved brethren, that without
delay I have stirred myself up to inform you of the unbelief of certain
persons who say that “There was a time when the Son of God was
not ῟Ην
ποτε ὅτε οὐκ
ἦν ὁ υἱ& 232·ς
τοῦ θεοῦ. καὶ
Γέγονεν
ὕστερον ὁ
πρότερον μὴ
ὑπάρχων
τοιοῦτος
γενόμενος
ὅτε καί ποτε
γέγονεν οἷος
καὶ πᾶς
πέφυκεν
ἄνθρωπος;” and “He who previously had
no existence subsequently came into existence; and when at some time He
came into existence He became such as every other man is.” God,
they say, created all things out of that which was non-existent, and
they include in the number of creatures, both rational and irrational,
even the Son of God. Consistently with this doctrine they, as a
necessary consequence, affirm that He is by nature liable to change,
and capable both of virtue and of vice, and thus, by their hypothesis
of his having been created out of that which was non-existent, they
overthrow the testimony of the Divine Scriptures, which declare the
immutability of the Word and the Divinity of the Wisdom of the Word,
which Word and Wisdom is Christ. ‘We are also able,’ say
these accursed wretches, ‘to become like Him, the sons of God;
for it is written,—I have nourished and brought up
children Isai. i. 2 ὑιοὺς
ἐγέννησα καὶ
ὕψωσα, as in Sept.
Vulg., filios enutrivi et exaltavi. Revd., marg., “made
great and exalted.”.’ When the continuation of this
text is brought before them, which is, ‘and they have rebelled
against Me,’ and it is objected that these words are
inconsistent with the Saviour’s nature, which is immutable, they
throw aside all reverence, and affirm that God foreknew and foresaw
that His Son would not rebel against Him, and that He therefore chose
Him in preference to all others. They likewise assert that He was not
chosen because He had by nature any thing superior to the other sons of
God; for no man, say they, is son of God by nature, nor has any
peculiar relation to Him. He was chosen, they allege, because, though
mutable by nature, His painstaking character suffered no deterioration.
As though, forsooth, even if a Paul and a Peter made like endeavours,
their sonship would in no respects differ from His.