There are many other astounding falsehoods also
which we must not weary your ears, beloved, with enumerating. But
after all these various impieties, which are closely connected by the
relationship that exists between one form of blasphemy and another, we
call your devout attention to the avoiding of these two errors in
particular: one of which, with Nestorius for its author, some
time ago attempted to gain ground, but ineffectually; the other, which
is equally damnable, has more recently sprung up with Eutyches as its
propounder. The former dared to maintain that the blessed Virgin
Mary was the mother of Christ’s manhood only, so that in her
conception and childbearing no union might be believed to have taken
place of the Word and the Flesh: because the Son of God did not Himself become Son of Man, but of His mere
condescension linked Himself with created man. This can in no
wise be tolerated by catholic ears, which are so imbued with the gospel
of Truth that they know of a surety there is no hope of salvation for
mankind unless He were Himself the Son of the Virgin who was His
mother’s Creator. On the other hand this blasphemous
propounder of more recent profanity has confessed the union of the two
Natures in Christ, but has maintained that the effect of this very
union is that of the two one remained while the substance of the other
no longer existed, which of course could not have been brought to an
end except by either destruction or separation It is doubtful
whether Eutyches did ever actually say this, but it was the logical
inference from his position: as Gore (p 57), says “Eutyches
never formulated a heresy: he was no philosopher; but he refused
to say that the human nature remained in Christ after the
Incarnation. He shrank from calling Christ ‘of one
substance’ with us men: in some sort of way he left us to
suppose that the human nature was absorbed into and lost in the
Divinity.”. But this is so opposed to sound
faith that it cannot be entertained without loss of one’s
Christian name. For if the Incarnation of the Word is the uniting
of the Divine and human natures, but by the very fact of their coming
together that which was twofold became single, it was only the Godhead
that was born of the Virgin’s womb, and went through the
deceptive appearance of receiving nourishment and bodily growth:
and to pass over all the changes of the human state, it was only the
Godhead that was crucified, dead, and buried: so that according
to those who thus think, there is no reason to hope for the
resurrection, and Christ is not “the first-begotten from the
dead Col. i. 18.;” because He was not One who
ought to have been raised again, if He had not been One who could be
slain.