wast thou not with me in prison during the persecution? And I lost an eye in behalf of the
truth, but thou appearest to have received no bodily injury, neither hast thou suffered
martyrdom, but thou hast remained alive with no mutilation. How wast thou released from
prison unless thou didst promise those that put upon us the pressure of persecution to do
that which is unlawful, or didst actually do it?” Eusebius, it seems, did not deny the charge,
but simply rose in anger and dismissed the council with the words, “If ye come hither and
make such accusations against us, then do your accusers speak the truth. For if ye tyrannize
here, much more do ye in your own country” (Epiphan. Hær. LXVIII. 8). It must be noticed,
however, that Potamo does not directly charge Eusebius with dishonorable conduct, he
simply conjectures that he must have acted dishonorably in order to escape punishment; as
if every one who was imprisoned with Potamo must have suffered as he did! As Stroth
suggests, it is quite possible that his peculiarly excitable and violent temperament was one
of the causes of his own loss. He evidently in any case had no knowledge of unworthy conduct
on Eusebius’ part, nor had any one else so far as we can judge. For in that age of bitter con-
troversy, when men’s characters were drawn by their opponents in the blackest lines, Euse-
bius must have suffered at the hands of the Athanasian party if it had been known that he
had acted a cowardly part in the persecution. Athanasius himself refers to this incident
10
(Contra Arian. VIII. 1), but he only says that Eusebius was “accused of sacrificing,” he does
not venture to affirm that he did sacrifice; and thus it is evident that he knew nothing of
such an act. Moreover, he never calls Eusebius “the sacrificer,” as he does Asterius, and as
he would have been sure to do had he possessed evidence which warranted him in making
the accusation (cf. Lightfoot, p. 311). Still further, Eusebius’ subsequent election to the
episcopate of Cæsarea, where his character and his conduct during the persecution must
have been well known, and his appointment in later life to the important see of Antioch,
forbid the supposition that he had ever acted a cowardly part in time of persecution. And
finally, it is psychologically impossible that Eusebius could have written works so full of
comfort for, and sympathy with, the suffering confessors, and could have spoken so openly
and in such strong terms of condemnation of the numerous defections that occurred during
the persecution, if he was conscious of his own guilt. It is quite possible, as remarked above,
that influential friends protected him without any act of compromise on his part; or, sup-
posing him to have been imprisoned with Potamo, it may be, as Lightfoot suggests, that the
close of the persecution brought him his release as it did so many others. For it would seem
natural to refer that imprisonment to the latter part of the persecution, when in all probab-
ility he visited Egypt, which was the home of Potamo. We must in any case vindicate Euse-
bius from the unfounded charge of cowardice and apostasy; and we ask, with Cave, “If every
accusation against any man at any time were to be believed, who would be guiltless?”
16
The Persecution of Diocletian.