In examining such a question, two methods are
possible. We may take as our point of departure the formulated dogma
say of Nicæa, and examine in the light of it variations in
theological statements in preceding periods, to shew that they do not
warrant us in regarding the dogma as an innovation. That is the
dogmatic method. Or we may take our start from the beginning, and trace
the history of doctrine in the order of cause and effect, so as to
detect the divergence and convergence of streams of influence, and
arrive at an answer to the question, How came men to think and speak as
they did? That is the historical method. Both methods have their
recommendations, and either has been ably applied to the problem before
us. In electing the latter I choose the more difficult road; but I do
so with the conviction, firstly, that the former has tended (and
especially in the ablest hands) to obscure our perception of the actual
facts, secondly, that the saving faith of Christ has everything to gain
from a method which appeals directly to our sense of historical truth,
and satisfies, not merely overawes, the mind.