I will now once more subjoin the
actual language of my opponent, word for word. It runs
thus:—“While there are,” he says, “two
statements which we have made, the one, that the essence of the
Only-begotten was not before its own generation, the other, that, being
generated, it was before all things—”What kind of
generation does our dogmatist propose to us? Is it one of which we may
fittingly think and speak in regard to God? And who is so godless as to
pre-suppose non-existence in God? But it is clear that he has in view
this material generation of ours, and is making the lower nature the
teacher of his conceptions concerning the Only-begotten God, and since
an ox or an ass or a camel is not before its own generation, he thinks
it proper to say even of the Only-begotten God that which the course of
the lower nature presents to our view in the case of the animals,
without thinking, corporeal theologian that he is, of this fact, that
the predicate “Only-begotten”, applied to God,
signifies by the very word itself that which is not in common with all
begetting, and is peculiar to Him. How could the term
“Only-begotten” be used of this “generation,”
if it had community and identity of meaning with other generation? That
there is something unique and exceptional to be understood in His case,
which is not to be remarked in other generation, is distinctly and
suitably expressed by the appellation of “Only-begotten”;
as, were any element of the lower generation conceived in it, He Who in
respect of any of the attributes of His generation was placed on a
level with other things that are begotten would no longer be
“Only-begotten.” For if the same things are to be
said of Him which are said of the other things that come into being by
generation, the definition will transform the sense of
“Only-begotten” to signify a kind of relationship involving
brotherhood. If then the sense of “Only-begotten” points to
absence of mixture and community with the rest of generated things, we
shall not admit that anything which we behold in the lower generation
is also to be conceived in the case of that existence which the Son has
from the Father. But non-existence before generation is proper to all
things that exist by generation: therefore this is foreign to the
special character of the Only-begotten, to which the name
“Only-begotten” bears witness that there attaches nothing
belonging to the mode of that form of common generation which Eunomius
misapprehends. Let this materialist and friend of the senses be
persuaded therefore to correct the error of his conception by the other
forms of generation. What will you say when you hear of the
“brightness of glory” or of the “savour of ointment Heb. i. 3, and Cant. i.
3,
referred to above.?” That the “brightness” was
not before its own generation? But if you answer thus, you will surely
admit that neither did the “glory” exist, nor the
“ointment”: for it is not possible that the
“glory” should be conceived as having existed by itself,
dark and lustreless, or the “ointment” without producing
its sweet breath: so that if the “brightness” “was
not,” the “glory” also surely “was not,”
and the “savour” being non-existent, there is also proved
the non-existence of the “ointment.” But if these examples
taken from Scripture excite any man’s fear, on the ground that
they do not accurately present to us the majesty of the Only-begotten,
because neither is essentially the same with its
substratum—neither the exhalation with the ointment, nor the beam
with the sun—let the true Word correct his fear, Who was in the
Beginning and is all that the Beginning is, and existent before all;
since John so declares in his preaching, “And the Word was with
God, and the Word was God S. John i. 1.” If then the
Father is God and the Son is God, what doubt still remains with regard
to the perfect Divinity of the Only-begotten, when by the sense of the
word “Son” is acknowledged the close relationship of
Nature, by “brightness” the conjunction and inseparability,
and by the appellation of “God,” applied alike to the
Father and the Son, their absolute equality, while the “express
image,” contemplated in reference to the whole Person ὑποστάσει of the Father, marks the absence of any
defect in the Son’s proper greatness, and the “form of
God” indicates His complete identity by showing in itself all
those marks by which the Godhead is betokened.