We cannot doubt that the earliest tradition made Evodius first
bishop of Antioch, for otherwise we could not explain the insertion of
his name before the great name of Ignatius. The tendency would be, of
course, to connect Ignatius directly with the apostles, and to make him
the first bishop. This tendency is seen in Athanasius and Chrysostom,
who do not mention Evodius at all; also in the Apost. Const.
VII. 46, where, however, it is said that Evodius was ordained by Peter,
and Ignatius by Paul (as in the parallel case of Clement of Rome). The
fact that the name of Evodius appears here shows that the tradition
that he was the first bishop seemed to the author too old and too
strong to be set aside. Origen (in Luc. Hom. VI.) is an indirect
witness to the episcopacy of Evodius, since he makes Ignatius the
second, and not the first, bishop of Antioch. As to the respective
dates of the early bishops of Antioch, we know nothing certain. On
their chronology, see Harnack, Die Zeit des Ignatius, and cf.
Salmon’s article Evodius, in Smith and Wace’s
Dict. of Christ. Biog.