the heresy, and thus these persons were expelled from the Church and debarred from
communion.”
11. Having related these things at the outset, and continued the refutation of their delu-
sion through his entire work, in the second book he speaks as follows of their end:
12. “Since, therefore, they called us slayers of the prophets1588 because we did not receive
their loquacious prophets, who, they say, are those that the Lord promised to send to the
people,1589 let them answer as in God’s presence: Who is there, O friends, of these who
began to talk, from Montanus and the women down, that was persecuted by the Jews, or
slain by lawless men? None. Or has any of them been seized and crucified for the Name?
Truly not. Or has one of these women ever been scourged in the synagogues of the Jews, or
stoned? No; never anywhere.1590
13. But by another kind of death Montanus and Maximilla are said to have died. For
the report is that, incited by the spirit of frenzy, they both hung themselves;1591 not at the
same time, but at the time which common report gives for the death of each. And thus they
died, and ended their lives like the traitor Judas.
14. So also, as general report says, that remarkable person, the first steward,1592 as it
were, of their so-called prophecy, one Theodotus—who, as if at sometime taken up and re-
1588 Cf. the complaint of Maximilla, quoted in §17, below. The words are employed, of course, only in the
figurative sense to indicate the hostility of the Church toward the Montanists. The Church, of course, had at
that time no power to put heretics to death, even if it had wished to do so. The first instance of the punishment
of heresy by death occurred in 385, when the Spanish bishop Priscillian and six companions were executed at
Trêves.
1589 Cf. Matt. xxiii. 34.
1590 There is a flat contradiction between this passage and §21, below, where it is admitted by this same author
that the Montanists have had their martyrs. The sweeping statements here, considered in the light of the admission
made in the other passage, furnish us with a criterion of the trustworthiness and honesty of the reports of our
anonymous author. It is plain that, in his hostility to Montanism, he has no regard whatever for the truth; that
his aim is to paint the heretics as black as possible, even if he is obliged to misrepresent the facts. We might,
from the general tone of the fragment which Eusebius has preserved, imagine this to be so: the present passage
proves it. We know, indeed, that the Montanists had many martyrs and that their principles were such as to
lead them to martyrdom, even when the Catholics avoided it (cf. Tertullian’s De fuga in persecutione).
1591 Whether this story is an invention of our author’s, or whether it was already in circulation, as he says,
we cannot tell. Its utter worthlessness needs no demonstration. Even our anonymous author does not venture
to call it certain.
1592 ἐπίτροπος: a steward, or administrator of funds. The existence of such an officer shows that the
Montanists formed a compact organization at an early date, and that much stress was laid upon it (cf. chap. 18,
§2). According to Jerome (Ep. ad Marcellam; Migne, Ep. XLI. 3) the Montanists at Pepuza had three classes of
officers: first, Patriarchs; second, Cenonæ; third, Bishops (Habent enim primos de Pepusa Phrygiæ Patriarchas:
549
The Circumstances related of Montanus and his False Prophets.