Chrys. adopts the view which was common in antiquity as to who the
“weak” here mentioned were. He regards them as judaizing
Christians who were over-zealous for the Mosaic law and even went
beyond its explicit requirements to abstain from swine’s flesh
and abstained from meat altogether. Another class of interpreters have
supposed that the scruples of the “weak” concerning meat
had the same ground as in 1 Cor. viii. and 1 Cor. x., viz., the fear of
eating flesh and drinking wine that had been used in the heathen
sacrificial worship (So Rückert, Philippi, Neander). The chief
objection to the former view is that they could not have derived their
doctrine of entire abstinence from meat and wine from the Mosaic law,
which prohibits only the flesh of certain unclean animals and does not
prohibit wine at all except in particular cases. The difficulty with
the second view is that the whole passage has no allusion to heathen
sacrifices, which could hardly have been the case if they had been the
ground of the scruple. On the contrary in v. 14 Paul in correcting these ascetic notions declares his
conviction that nothing is “unclean of itself,”
showing that their view was that flesh and wine possessed in
themselves some power of pollution. The difficulties connected with
these explanations have led many recent scholars to different
explanations. Baur regarded the “weak” as Ebionitic
Christians, but the Ebionites abstained from flesh as inherently sinful
and it would seem that if this had been the opinion of the
“weak” that Paul could hardly have treated it so mildly.
Since the Ebionites date from about 70 a.d.,
these ascetics at Rome could have been Ebionitic only in the sense of
having the germs of subsequent Ebionism. An opinion similar to this has
been advocated by Ritschl, Meyer and Mangold. In their view the root of
this asceticism was Essenic. There was certainly a Judeo-Christian
minority in the Roman church. The ideas of the Essenes were widely
disseminated among the Jews at the time. It is natural to suppose that
among the Roman Jews there were Essenes or those of Essenic tendencies
who upon their conversion would associate their rigorous asceticism
with the Christian doctrine of the subjugation of the flesh. This view
best meets the requirements of the passage. The Essenes abstained
wholly from wine and practised a supra-legal regimen in regard to food.
They would have no occasion to array themselves against the
apostle’s doctrine and he therefore treats their scruples not in
a polemic but in a cautious and conciliatory
spirit.—G.B.S.