to this: that no one can be involved in the guilt of unknown crimes committed by persons
unknown to him. Whence it is manifest that you have been guilty of impious schism in
separating yourselves from the communion of the whole world, to which the things charged,
whether truly or falsely, by you against some men in Africa, have been and still are wholly
unknown; although this also should not be forgotten, that even when known and discovered,
bad men do not harm the good who are in a Church, if either the power of restraining them
from communion be wanting, or the interests of the Church’s peace forbid this to be done.
For who were those who, according to the prophet Ezekiel,2087 obtained the reward of being
marked before the destruction of the wicked, and of escaping unhurt when they were des-
troyed, but those who sighed and cried for the sins and iniquities of the people of God which
were done in the midst of them? Now who sighs and cries for that which is unknown to
him? On the same principle, the Apostle Paul bears with false brethren. For it is not of persons
unknown to him that he says, “All seek their own, not the things which are Jesus Christ’s;”
yet these persons he shows plainly to have been beside him. And to what class do the men
belong who have chosen rather to burn incense to idols or surrender the divine books than
to suffer death, if not to those who “seek their own, not the things of Jesus Christ”?
3. I omit many proofs which I might give from Scripture, that I may not make this letter
longer than is needful; and I leave many more things to be considered by yourself in the
light of your own learning. But I beseech you mark this, which is quite enough to decide
the whole question: If so many transgressors in the one nation, which was then the Church
of God, did not make those who were associated with them to be guilty like themselves; if
that multitude of false brethren did not make the Apostle Paul, who was a member of the
same Church with them, a seeker not of the things of Jesus Christ, but of his own,—it is
manifest that a man is not made wicked by the wickedness of any one with whom he goes
to the altar of Christ, even though he be not unknown to him, provided only that he do not
encourage him in his wickedness, but by a good conscience disallowing his conduct keep
himself apart from him. It is therefore obvious that, to be art and part with a thief, one must
either help him in the theft, or receive with approbation what he has stolen. This I say in
order to remove out of the way endless and unnecessary questions concerning the conduct
of men, which are wholly irrelevant when advanced against our position.
4. If, however, you do not agree with what I have said, you involve the whole of your
party in the reproach of being such men as Optatus was, while, notwithstanding your
knowledge of his crimes, he was tolerated in communion with you; and far be it from me
to say this of such a man as Emeritus, and of others of like integrity among you, who are, I
am sure, wholly averse to such deeds as disgraced him. For we do not lay any charge against
you but the one of schism, which by your obstinate persistence in it you have now made
2087 Ezek. ix. 4-6
816
To Emeritus