The general continued wickedness of mankind, against such means and motives, proves
each of these things, viz. that the cause is fixed, and that the fixed cause is internal in man’s
nature, and also that it is very powerful. It proves, that the cause is fixed, because the effect
is so abiding, through so many changes. It proves that the fixed cause is internal, because
the circumstances are so various—including a variety of means and motives—and they are
such circumstances as cannot possibly cause the effect, being most opposite to it in their
tendency. And it proves the greatness of the internal cause; or that the propensity is powerful;
because the means which have opposed its influence, have been so great, and yet have been
statedly overcome.
But here I may observe, by the way, that with regard to the motives and obligations
against which our first father sinned, it is not reasonably alleged, that he sinned when he
knew his sin would have destructive consequences to all his posterity, and might in process
of time, pave the whole globe with skulls, &c. It is evident, by the plain account the scripture
gives us of the temptation which prevailed with our first parents to commit that sin, that it
was so contrived by the subtlety of the tempter, as first to blind and deceive them as to that
matter, and to make them believe that their disobedience should be followed with no destruc-
tion or calamity at all to themselves (and therefore not to their posterity,) but on the contrary,
with a great increase and advancement of dignity and happiness.
Evasion II. Let the wickedness of the world be ever so general and great, there is no ne-
cessity of supposing any depravity of nature to be the cause: man’s own free will is cause
sufficient. Let mankind be more or less corrupt, they make themselves corrupt by their own
free choice. This Dr. T. abundantly insists upon, in many parts of his book . 19
But I would ask, how it comes to pass that mankind so universally agree in this evil ex-
ercise of their free will? If their wills are in the first place as free to good as to evil, what is it
to be ascribed to, that the world of mankind, consisting of so many millions, in so many
successive generations, without consultation, all agree to exercise their freedom in favour
of evil? If there be no natural tendency or preponderation in the case, then there is as good
a chance for the will being determined to good as to evil. If the cause be indifferent, why is
not the effect in some measure indifferent? If the balance be no heavier at one end than the
other, why does it perpetually preponderate one way? How comes it to pass, that the free
will of mankind has been determined to evil, in like manner before the flood and after the
flood; under the law and under the gospel; among both Jews and Gentiles, under the Old
Testament, and since then, among Christians, Jews, Mahometans; among papists and prot-
estants; in those nations where civility, politeness, arts, and learning most prevail, and among
the Negroes and Hottentots in Africa, the Tartars in Asia, and Indians in America, towards
both the poles, and on every side of the globe; in greatest cities and obscurest villages; in
19 Page 257, 258, 52, 53. S. and many other places.
998
SECTION IX. Several evasions considered.