We
learn from Lactantius (l.c.) that the officers of the church,
under the terms of the second edict, were thrown into prison without
any option being given them in the matter of sacrificing. They were not
asked to sacrifice, but were imprisoned unconditionally. This was so
far in agreement with Valerian’s edict, which had decreed the
instant death of all church officers without the option of sacrificing.
But as Eusebius tells us here, they were afterwards called upon to
sacrifice, and as he tells us in the first paragraph of the next
chapter, multitudes yielded, and that of course meant their release, as
indeed we are directly told in chap. 6, §10. We may gather from
the present passage and from the other passages referred to, taken in
connection with the second chapter of the Martyrs of Palestine,
that this decree, ordaining their release on condition of sacrificing,
was issued on the occasion of Diocletian’s Vicennalia, which were
celebrated in December, 303, on the twentieth anniversary of the death
of Carus, which Diocletian reckoned as the beginning of his reign,
though he was not in reality emperor until the following September. A
considerable time, therefore, elapsed between the edict ordaining the
imprisonment of church officers and the edict commanding their release
upon condition of sacrificing. This latter is commonly known as
Diocletian’s Third Edict, and is usually spoken of as still
harsher than any that preceded it. It is true that it did result in the
torture of a great many,—for those who did not sacrifice readily
were to be compelled to do so, if possible,—but their death was
not aimed at. If they would not sacrifice, they were simply to remain
in prison, as before. Those who did die at this time seem to have died
under torture that was intended, not to kill them, but to bring about
their release. As Mason shows, then, this third edict was of the nature
of an amnesty; was rather a step toward toleration than a sharpening of
the persecution. The prisons were to be emptied, as was customary on
such great occasions, and the church officers were to be permitted to
return to their homes, on condition that they should sacrifice.
Inasmuch as they had not been allowed to leave prison on any condition
before, this was clearly a mark of favor (see Mason, p. 206 sq.). Many
were released even without sacrificing, and in their desire to empty
the prisons, the governors devised various expedients for freeing at
least a part of those who would not yield (cf. the instances mentioned
in the next chapter). At the same time, some governors got rid of their
prisoners by putting them to death, sometimes simply by increasing the
severity of the tortures intended to try them, sometimes as a penalty
for rash or daring words uttered by the prisoners, which were
interpreted as treasonable, and which, perhaps, the officials had
employed their ingenuity, when necessary, to elicit. Thus many might
suffer death, under various legal pretenses, although the terms of the
edict did not legally permit death to be inflicted as a punishment for
Christianity. The death penalty was not decreed until the issue of the
Fourth Edict (see below, Mart. Pal. chap.3, note 2).