2. You, however, beloved and most truly
longed-for, have done what befitted the tradition of the Church and
your piety toward the Lord, in refuting, admonishing, and rebuking such
men. But since, instigated by their father the devil, ‘they knew
not nor understood,’ as it is written, ‘but go on still in
darkness Ps. lxxxii. 5.,’ let them learn from your piety
that this error of theirs belongs to Valentinus and Marcion, and to
Manichæus, of whom some substituted [the idea of] Appearance for
Reality, while the others, dividing what is indivisible, denied the
truth that ‘the Word was made Flesh, and dwelt among us John i. 14..’ Why then, as they hold with those
people, do they not also take up the heritage of their names? For it is
reasonable, as they hold their error, to have their names as well, and
for the future to be called Valentinians, Marcionists, and
Manichæans. Perhaps even thus, being put to shame by the ill
savour of the names, they may be enabled to perceive into what a depth
of impiety they have fallen. And it would be within our rights not to
answer them at all, according to the apostolic advice Tit. iii. 10,
11.: ‘A man that is heretical, after a
first and second admonition refuse, knowing that such an one is
perverted, and sinneth, being self-condemned;’ the more so, in
that the Prophet says about such men: ‘The fool shall utter
foolishness, and his heart shall imagine vain things Isa. xxxii. 6, LXX..’ But since, like their leader, they
too go about like lions seeking whom among the simple they shall
devour 1 Pet. v. 8., we are compelled to write in reply to
your piety, that the brethren being once again instructed by your
admonition may still further reprobate the vain teaching of those
men.