viii
Some portions are mere literal translations, and some are done into more idiomatic English,
but all—so far as I am able to judge—are fair renderings of the original, its ambiguities being
duly preserved. I have used as the foundation of the translation of the canons of the first
four synods and of the five Provincial Synods that most convenient book, Index Canonum,
by the Rev. John Fulton, D.D., D.C.L., in which united to a good translation is a Greek text,
very well edited and clearly printed.
In preparing the other division of the book, that is to say, the Introduction and Notes,
I have been guided by the same considerations. Here will be found no new and brilliant
guesses of my own, but a collection of the most reliable conclusions of the most weighty
critics and commentators. Where the notes are of any length I have traced the source and
given the exact reference, but for the brief notes, where I have not thought this necessary,
the reader may feel the greatest confidence that he is not reading any surmises of mine, but
that in every particular what he reads rests upon the authority of the greatest names who
have written on the subject. In the bibliographical table already referred to I have placed
the authorities most frequently cited.
I think it necessary to make a few remarks upon the rule which I have laid down for
myself with regard to my attitude on controverted questions bearing upon doctrine or ec-
clesiastical discipline. It seems to me that in such a work as the present any expression of
the editor’s views would be eminently out of place. I have therefore confined myself to a
bare statement of what I conceive to be the facts of the case, and have left the reader to draw
from them what conclusions he pleases. I hope that this volume may be equally acceptable
to the Catholic and to the Protestant, to the Eastern and to the Western, and while I naturally
think that the facts presented are clearly in accordance with my own views, I hope that those
who draw from the same premises different conclusions will find these premises stated to
their satisfaction in the following pages. And should such be the case this volume may well
be a step toward “the union of all” and toward “the peace of all the holy churches of God,”
for which the unchanging East has so constantly prayed in her liturgy.
I wish to explain to the reader one other principle on which I have proceeded in preparing
this volume. It professes to be a translation of the decrees and canons of certain ecclesiast-
ical synods. It is not a history of those synods, nor is it a theological treatise upon the truth
or otherwise of the doctrines set forth by those synods in their legislation. I have therefore
carefully restricted my own historical introductions to a bare statement of such facts as
seemed needed to render the meaning of the matter subsequently presented intelligible to
the reader. And with regard to doctrine I have pursued the same course, merely explaining
what the doctrine taught or condemned was, without entering into any consideration of its
truth or falsity. For the history of the Church and its Councils the reader must consult the
great historians; for a defence of the Church’s faith he must read the works of her theologians.
3
Preface.