and grace, condemnation and justification—all come to nothing. And this whole discourse
of the apostle, wherein he seems to labour much, as if it were to set forth some very grand
and most important distinction and oppositions in the state of things, as derived from the
two great heads of mankind, proves nothing but a multitude of words without meaning, or
rather a heap of inconsistencies.
V. Our author’s own doctrine entirely makes void what he supposes to be the apostle’s
argument, in Rom. v. 13, 14 , in these words; “For until the law, sin was in the world: but
sin is not imputed where there is no law. Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses,
even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam’s transgression.”
What he supposes the apostle would prove here, is, that the mortality of mankind comes
only by Adam’s sin, and not by men’s personal sins, because there was no law threatening
death to Adam’s posterity for personal sins, before the law of Moses; but death, or the mor-
tality of Adam’s posterity, took place many ages before the law was given; therefore death
could not be by any law threatening death for personal sins, and consequently could be by
nothing but Adam’s sin. 79 On this I would observe,
1. That which he supposes the apostle to take for a truth in this argument, viz. That
there was no law of God in being, by which men were exposed to death for personal sin,
during the time from Adam to Moses, is neither true, nor agreeable to this apostle’s own
doctrine.
First, The assertion is not true. For the law of nature, written in men’s hearts, was then
in being, and was a law by which men were exposed to death for personal sin. That there
was a divine establishment, fixing the death and destruction of the sinner as the consequence
of personal sin, which was well known before the giving of the law by Moses, is plain by
many passages in the book of Job, as fully and clearly implying a connexion between such
sin and such a punishment, as any passage in the law of Moses: such as that in Job xxiv.
19.“Drought and heat consume the snow-waters; so doth the grave them that have sinned.”
202
(Compare Job. xxiv. 20, 24.) Also Job xxxvi. 6. “He preserveth not the life of the wicked.”
Job xxi. 29-32, “Have ye not asked them that go by the way ? and do ye not know their
tokens? That the wicked is reserved to the day of destruction; they shall be brought forth to
the day of wrath.” Job xxi. 32. “He shall be wrought to the grave.” 80
Secondly. To suppose that there is no law in being, by which men are exposed to death
for personal sin, when a revealed law of God is not in being, is contrary to our apostle’s own
doctrine in this epistle. Rom. ii. 12, 14, 15. ” For as many as have sinned without law (i. e.
79 Page 40, 41, 43, 57. and often elsewhere.
80 See also Job iv. 7, 8, 9. Job xv. 17-35. Job xviii. 5-21. Job xix. 29. and Job xx. 4-8, 23-29. Job xxi 16-18,
20-26. Job xxii. 13-20 and Job xxvii. 11-23 Job xxxi. 3,23 Job xxxiii. 18,22,23,24,28,30. Job xxxiv. 11, 21-26.
Job xxxvii. 12, 18, 19, 20. and Job xxxviii. 13.
1092
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.