Chapter XXVIII.
In what Way, on collating the consentient opinions of the Ancient Masters, the Novelties
of Heretics may be detected and condemned.
[71.] And here I perceive that, as a necessary sequel to the foregoing, I ought to show
by examples in what way, by collating the consentient opinions of the ancient masters, the
profane novelties of heretics may be detected and condemned. Yet in the investigation of
this ancient consent of the holy Fathers we are to bestow our pains not on every minor
question of the Divine Law, but only, at all events especially, where the Rule of Faith is
concerned. Nor is this way of dealing with heresy to be resorted to always, or in every in-
stance, but only in the case of those heresies which are new and recent, and that on their
first arising, before they have had time to deprave the Rules of the Ancient Faith, and before
they endeavour, while the poison spreads and diffuses itself, to corrupt the writings of the
ancients. But heresies already widely diffused and of old standing are by no means to be
thus dealt with, seeing that through lapse of time they have long had opportunity of corrupt-
ing the truth. And therefore, as to the more ancient schisms or heresies, we ought either to
confute them, if need be, by the sole authority of the Scriptures, or at any rate, to shun them
as having been already of old convicted and condemned by universal councils of the Cath-
olic Priesthood.
[72.] Therefore, as soon as the corruption of each mischievous error begins to break
forth, and to defend itself by filching certain passages of Scripture, and expounding them
fraudulently and deceitfully, forthwith, the opinions of the ancients in the interpretation of
the Canon are to be collected, whereby the novelty, and consequently the profaneness,
whatever it may be, that arises, may both without any doubt be exposed, and without any
tergiversation be condemned. But the opinions of those Fathers only are to be used for
comparison, who living and teaching, holily, wisely, and with constancy, in the Catholic
faith and communion, were counted worthy either to die in the faith of Christ, or to suffer
death happily for Christ. Whom yet we are to believe on this condition, that that only is to
be accounted indubitable, certain, established, which either all, or the more part, have sup-
ported and confirmed manifestly, frequently, persistently, in one and the same sense,
forming, as it were, a consentient council of doctors, all receiving, holding, handing on the
same doctrine. But whatsoever a teacher holds, other than all, or contrary to all, be he holy
and learned, be he a bishop, be he a Confessor, be he a martyr, let that be regarded as a
private fancy of his own, and be separated from the authority of common, public, general
persuasion, lest, after the sacrilegious custom of heretics and schismatics, rejecting the ancient
truth of the universal Creed, we follow, at the utmost peril of our eternal salvation, the newly
devised error of one man.
[73.] Lest any one perchance should rashly think the holy and Catholic consent of these
blessed fathers to be despised, the Apostle says, in the First Epistle to the Corinthians, “God
Chapter XXVIII. In what Way, on collating the consentient opinions of the Ancient Masters, the Novelties of Heretics may be detected and condemned.
353
Chapter XXVIII. In what Way, on collating the consentient opinions of the…