Letter CLXXIII.
(a.d. 416.)
To Donatus, a Presbyter of the Donatist Party, Augustin, a Bishop of the Catholic
Church, Sends Greeting.
1. If you could see the sorrow of my heart and my concern for your salvation, you would
perhaps take pity on your own soul, doing that which is pleasing to God, by giving heed to
the word which is not ours but His; and would no longer give to His Scripture only a place
in your memory, while shutting it out from your heart. You are angry because you are being
drawn to salvation, although you have drawn so many of our fellow Christians to destruction.
For what did we order beyond this, that you should be arrested, brought before the author-
ities, and guarded, in order to prevent you from perishing? As to your having sustained
bodily injury, you have yourself to blame for this, as you would not use the horse which was
immediately brought to you, and then dashed yourself violently to the ground; for, as you
well know, your companion, who was brought along with you, arrived uninjured, not having
done any harm to himself as you did.
2. You think, however, that even what we have done to you should not have been done,
because, in your opinion, no man should be compelled to that which is good. Mark, therefore,
the words of the apostle: “If a man desire the office of a bishop, he desireth a good work,”
and yet, in order to make the office of a bishop be accepted by many men, they are seized
against their will,2812 subjected to importunate persuasion, shut up and detained in custody,
and made to suffer so many things which they dislike, until a willingness to undertake the
good work is found in them. How much more, then, is it fitting that you should be drawn
forcibly away from a pernicious error, in which you are enemies to your own souls, and
brought to acquaint yourselves with the truth, or to choose it when known, not only in order
to your holding in a safe and advantageous way the honour belonging to your office, but
also in order to preserve you from perishing miserably! You say that God has given us free
will, and that therefore no man should be compelled even to good. Why, then, are those
whom I have above referred to compelled to that which is good? Take heed, therefore, to
something which you do not wish to consider. The aim towards which a good will compas-
sionately devotes its efforts is to secure that a bad will be rightly directed. For who does not
know that a man is not condemned on any other ground than because his bad will deserved
it, and that no man is saved who has not a good will? Nevertheless, it does not follow from
this that those who are loved should be cruelly left to yield themselves with impunity to
their bad will; but in so far as power is given, they ought to be both prevented from evil and
compelled to good.
2812 An example is furnished in the case of Castorius, Letter LXIX.; Letters, p. 326.
To Donatus
1154
To Donatus